At-Large Metrics Working Group 

Date: Thursday, 13 November 2014

Time: 17:00 - 18:30 UTC (for the time in various timezones click here)

Meeting Number: AL.MTC/MT.1114/1

---

How can I participate in this meeting?     

Adobe Connect Meeting Room: http://icann.adobeconnect.com/metrics-wg/

---

Action Items:  At-Large Metrics Working Group 2014.11.13

 Recording: EN

Transcript: EN

AC Chat Transcript:  At-Large Metrics Working Group 2014.11.13

---

Participants: Chery Langdon-Orr, Maureen Hilyard, Oksana Pryhodko, Alan Greenberg, Siranush Vardanyan, Tijani Ben Jemma, Dev Anand Teelucksingh, Olivier Crepin-Leblond, Janvier Ngoulaye,

Apologies: NONE

Staff: Silvia Vivanco, Heidi Ulrich, Gisella Gruber, Kathy Schnitt

Call management: Kathy Schnitt

 

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

A G E N D A 

0. All WG Members requested to review  previous meeting -  Held in LA during ICANN 51;  13th October, 15:00 - 16:00 - At-Large Metrics Working Group 

• See: Los Angeles  Meeting Agendas Workspace ;    Recording of Meeting  Recording ;  Transcripts  EN, ES, FR

 

• • Records of previous meeting can be found here.  

 

1. Welcome & Attendance (2 min - CLO/Staff)

 

2. Review of the last meeting outcomes and  Action items of the meeting  (3 min - WG/Staff)

Last meeting - Action Items At-Large Metrics Working Group Meeting 2014.10.13 (from main LA Meeting ALAC Action Items page)

At-Large Metrics Working Group

•  Gisella Gruber to coordinate monthly teleconference calls for the Metrics WG .
• The WG will analyze recommendation 43 and how it can be relayed effectively to the group.
• Silvia Vivanco to follow up that at least 3 RALOs have some measure of attendance.
• A poll will be conducted via AC connect/ survey to harmonize RALO attendance percentages, at the ALAC/RALO/ At large structure.
• With the goal to have  a draft proposal by the November (25th) ALAC meeting.

 

3. Discussion and Review of Recommendation 43 from ATLAS II  {with specific reference to outcomes of LA Meeting and planned polling}  (10 minutes) 

Recommendation 43:

 

4. Preparation/Discussion of DRAFT Proposal to the ALAC based on a harmonization of Main Cross RALO {inclusive of Leadership and ALSes}  performance expectations/items/issues: (45 - 55 mins)

a. Key Points:

• Role Specific and Leadership expectations
  • • Specific to RALO ROP's
    • Specific to Other Guidelines/ROPs
    • General
      
      
• Attendance at Meetings, and Activities

*Percentages of Meetings to be attended

• • • • 50% to 75%
      • 75% to 85%
      • 85% +

*Classification(s) of ALAC/RALO/ALS Meetings and Activities

*Quorum Issues

*Parity in roles

*Apology and Leave of Absences

*Exception Rules and Requests

*

*

*

 

• Contributions to Policy and ICANN Specific Activity {including Outreach etc.,}

*

*

*

• Contributions to RALO Specific Activities and Requirements

*

*

*

 

• Consequences of below 'Par' performance
• Remedial Action
• Restrictions
  • Voting Rights
  • Representational Rights
  • Travel Support
  • Other
• Appeals Mechanisms
• Reparation

 

b.  Staged Implementation (discuss benefits and limitations of such)

 

c.  Sub Committees

• • Drafting
  • Administrative
    
    • ALAC/Cross Regional
    • Review/Audit
    • Appeals
    • Other

 

5. Next Steps Preparing for December 2014 meeting ( 5 mins)

Planning (discussion and suggestions) Agenda;  Review of Intersession Activities etc.,

6. AOB and review of AI's (5 min - CLO/Staff)

7. References:

See: LA Meeting Transcripts recordings and  FLIP CHART <please insert vision or copy of Chart here>

• Metrics – ALAC, RALO, and ALS Metric Expectations and Requirements Workspace
  • RALOs current activities re METRICs:

LACRALO, AFRALO are discussing metrics

See: AFRALO RULES OF PROCEDURE REVIEW 2014

See: LACRALO RULES OF PROCEDURE REVIEW

See: APRALO Rules of Procedure 2014

See: Post ATLAS II Activities Workspace

    ALAC (new) Rules of Procedure 2013

    ALS Metrics Should Do Activities

• Existing WG Wiki Pages