You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 5 Next »

MeetingDate/TimeReporter's Name & RALO AffiliationReport

Privacy Proxy Services

Friday 16 October 2015 – all day

(and reviewed at the meeting on 18 October 0800-0900)

 

Holly Raiche, ALAC/APRALO

The daylong meeting discussed outstanding issues raised by public comments in response to the Issues Paper. The outstanding issues (not finalised by earlier PPSAI meetings) include:

  • Whether/how lawyers (particularly in relation to lawyer/client confidentiality requirements) would be subject to the requirements of the specification.  The issue includes the possibility of individuals claiming to be lawyers so as not to reveal contact information, and the issue of when a client is covered by lawyer/client confidentiality protections
  • For the purposes of the report, the definition of law enforcement agencies.  The meeting agreed to use the definition of the term in the 2013 RAA
  • Whether the beneficial customer of a P/P service should have the option of terminating their domain name rather than have their contact details revealed. The meeting agreed that it would be left up to individual registrars, but that the P/P provider must include their policy on the issue in their terms of service.
  • The need for a post-implementation review, including time frames, data that would be required for the review
  • The need for an education campaign to explain the policy
  • Discussion on abuse of the rules – remedies for a breach and compliance issues

The group hopes to finalise its position on all outstanding issues within in next few weeks and it will then be subject to a consensus call.  At that time, I, as ALAC rep, will be asked if I agree with the report or have concerns

Leadership with FadiFriday 16: EveningGlenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC OutgoingThis  meeting was at the Westin Hotel:  Short  report on  NARALO involvement and  community feedback on the CCWG

ALAC


ALAC  Dinner

Saturday  17

 

Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC OutgoingEdit

At-Large Review Working Party

Sunday 18 October 2015

Holly Raiche, ALAC/APRALO

The meeting included presentations by Larisa Gurnick, Structural Improvements Committee, and Xavier Calvez, CFO. Larisa reviewed the timelines for the review, saying that the scope of work and selection criteria should be finalised by the end of October/early November.  From November to early March, the scope of work and criteria will be finalised, an RFP will be finalised, the bidders analysed and a selection of the independent examiner made.  The actual review will start in April.

Xavier talked to the procurement part of the process – the development of the RFP, and the selection of the Independent Examiner.  ALAC will contribute to the process through its input on criteria for the selection process and after completion of the REF process.  Because of the need for complete independence of the process, the actual applicants and selection process must be confidential.  Otherwise, the process will be as open as possible. 

Some of the lessons learned include the genuine buy-in of the community.  For action items, all those who are on the list of the WP should confirm their participation, and be tasked with input into the selection criteria. 

ALAC

Verisign @ Guiness Storehouse

Sunday 18Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC OutgoingEdit

DNS and Women

Opening  ceremonies and  Leadership Awards

INEx  President  Presentation

Fadi's Presidents  report

 

NARALO  Monthly Call

 

Gala Pub crawl

Monday 18

7 to  6

 

 

 

 

7 to 10

Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC Outgoing

Volunteered.  Video of three speakers

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHeYfhcpf4QTZ6R9ydm8vdhV_hDktK4uP

Pictures

https://www.flickr.com/photos/glennmcknight/albums/72157659951599445

( You  are welcome to download the pictures which have a  Creative Common's  Attribution License. Please do not  use  my pictures  without  acknowledging the source)
 

Normal  NARALO meeting and Garth Bruen's  last meeting as  Chair,  special guest  Allan Grogan, Compliance- discussion on consumer trust and ICANN outreach to the consumer groups

 

Meeting on Human Rights – focussing on privacy issues Convened by NCSG

Wednesday   21 October 2015, 0900-1015

Holly Raiche, ALAC/APRALO

The meeting first discussed ICANN policy issues that potentially have human rights implications. There was also discussion on the possibility of Human Right impact assessment models.  In the final segment, the author of the publication, ICANN’s Corporate Responsibility to Respect Human rights, spoke to the contents of the report and suggested ways in which human rights issues could be identified, addressed and documented in ICANN. In discussion concerns were raised about how the report’s recommendations could map to ICANN policies, what data might be needed, whether it can be collected and who/how ICANN’s performance would be assessed in human rights terms

 

ICANN  Fellowship Meeting

ALAC 1 and 2

NPOC  Meeting

Atlas  2 Recommendations

ALAC Outreach and  Engagement

Tuesday 19

7 am to  8 pm

Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC Outgoing

Presentations in ICANN  Dublin Playlist

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHeYfhcpf4QTZ6R9ydm8vdhV_hDktK4uP

Pictures
https://www.flickr.com/photos/glennmcknight/albums/72157659951599445

  • Leadership Award
  • President Report
  • INeX Presidentation

Late  meeting but  well attended  special  analysis of  Fellowship program and Invite to  Jeff Dunn and NetGen students.

Also  Adam Peake and  JJ Sahel, VP  spoke on the Civil Engagement document

Meeting with OmbudsmanWednesday 20Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC OutgoingPrivate

Registration Data Access Protocol (RDAP) Implementation   

1230 – 1345 Wednesday 21 October 2015

Holly Raiche, ALAC/APRALO

As a follow on from the EWG report, the IETF published a new protocol – RDAP – to replace the current WHOIS protocol 443.  The meeting first reviewed the history of the protocol – all of the problems with the existing Whois protocol and the features of the new protocol.  The meeting was to discuss the implementation of the protocol, to discuss the few issues left to resolve, and how to phase in the replacement of the Whois protocol with RADP. The particularly important features of RADP is that it will allow authentication of the requestor and, based on the identity of the requestor, (i.e., gated access to Whois information, based on requestor)  In the presentation, the presented suggested that use of the protocol by registries/registrars – particularly use of the features allowing gated access, could be optional.  There was immediate criticism that the features that would allow gated access should be mandatory.  The features that control access to contact information can be turned off until Whois policy is finalised, but it must be required that the features be mandatory so that, when privacy policies are finalised, the features that would implement the agreed policy are in place.

ALAC  Technical  Taskforce

 

ALAC  Meeting

Thursday  21

8 to 10pm

Glenn McKnight  NARALO Incoming Chair/ALAC Outgoing 
ALACFriday 22  

 

Example: At-Large Singapore Meeting Reports Workspace

  • No labels