Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

MtgDateAction

Action Owner

Due DateAction CompleteStatus
#38

Big picture issues: 1) make sure when rt refers to abuse that we refer to technical abuse 2) once all recommendations are  revised, review and crosscheck the report to make sure all is in the right place.Review Team

 

 

IN PROGRESS


CLOSED ACTIONS/REQUESTS

MtgDateAction

Action Owner

Due DateAction CompleteStatus
#43

Rec D: David to provide input to Drew, rec will be discussed on next subteam call.

David


 

COMPLETE
#43

Rec C: Recommendation to be circulated with the review team ahead of tomorrow's plenary call.

ICANN org

 

COMPLETE
#43

Rec 40, 41, 42: ICANN org to send amended recommentadions together with other recommendations fields to David for final verification. Upon greenlight, recommendations to be shared with the review team for review/approval.

ICANN org

 

COMPLETE
#43

Rec. 40: ICANN org to update last sentence of rec. 40 with : "The CCT acknowledges that the study was carried out in 2017 by a Nielsen survey of INTA members that yielded a lower response rate than anticipated. We note that this study should be more user friendly and perhaps shorter in order to help ensure a higher and more statistically significant response rate."

ICANN org

 

COMPLETE
#42

Drew to update recommendation E and submit it for discussion on next safeguards and trust subteam call.

Drew

 

COMPLETE
#42

Drew to circulate success measures via email on recommendations A, B, C.

Drew

 

COMPLETE
#42

ICANN org to update the document submitted by David on Rec 40, 41, 42, by adding the original “To, Priority, Details, and Success Measures”: See new version attached.

  • Subteam to review the recommendations 40, 41, 42, and discuss/confirm whether the “To, Priority, Details, and Success Measures” fields need to be updated as per the new recommendation text.

ICANN org


Subteam


 

COMPLETE
#42

David/Drew to discuss and update recommendation D, and submit it for discussion on next safeguards and trust subteam call.

David/Drew

 

COMPLETE
#41

 

David/Drew to refine language of Recommendation D and share for comment on the subteam list

David/Drew

 

COMPLETE
#41

 

David to work on Rec. 40, 41, 42 consolidation and share for comment on the subteam list

David

 

COMPLETE
#41

 

Drew to update recommendation C language based on input received during the call. Subteam to send any further comments to Drew.

Drew

 

COMPLETE
#40

Rec 40: David to add more context to the rationale concerning the sample size of the INTA study and how the data is indicative of trends. David to share an updated version of his paper based on input received prior to tomorrow’s plenary call

David
Udpdated version shared prior to Safeguards & Trust Call #42COMPLETE
#38

Rec 13, 15, 33: Drew to suggest to Laureen via email new language for the last success measure. Laureen to send an udpated version to the entire subteam to approve by Friday for circulate to RT with RT to object by next Friday. If none, updated recommendation will be included in the Final Report.Drew/Laureen


 

COMPLETE

#39

Rec A: Laureen to suggest new language to rationale/related findings section.

Laureen

 

 

COMPLETE
#39

Drew to send an email to the review team for them to review the latest version of the DNS Abuse Chapter before the plenary call tomorrow.

Drew

 


OVERDUE
#39

Rec B.: Drew to correct typo.

Drew

 

 

COMPLETE
#38

Big picture issues: 1) make sure when rt refers to abuse that we refer to technical abuse 2) once all recommendations are  revised, review and crosscheck the report to make sure all is in the right place.Review Team

 

 

COMPLETE
#38

Rec 21 (22), 23: Laureen to share a redline and clean version of recommendations to the entire subteam to approve by Friday for circulate to RT with RT to object by next Friday. If none, updated recommendation will be included in the Final Report.Laureen

 


COMPLETE
#38

- Rec. 31, 32: Laureen to share a redline and clean version of recommendations to the entire subteam to approve by Friday for circulate to RT with RT to object by next Friday. If none, updated recommendation will be included in the Final Report.Laureen

 


COMPLETE
#38

- Rec. 25-30: direct this to the subsequent procedures pdp working group. Laureen to look into whether the term study is the most appropriate term for the different steps mentioned within the recommendation. Laureen to re-circulate the updated version to the subteam for comments.Laureen

 


COMPLETE
#34

Rec. 17, 18: Calvin to add success measures, and details.CalvinDec 12, 2017

 

COMPLETE
#37

Gao to consolidate  recs. 13 & 15 into a single recommendation, and explain in an email how your consolidation relates to the public comments received, and send via email to the subgroup by the end of the week.

Gao

 

 

COMPLETE
#36

Recs 21, 22, 23: All to circulate feedback to Calrton by friday 15 December COB. Add recommendations for final review on next sub team call. (Carlton does not recommend consolidating these recommendations)Subteam members

 

 

COMPLETE
#36

Gao's recommendations to be moved to next week's subteam call.ICANN org

 

 

COMPLETE
#36

Rec. 24: Calvin to circulate proposal to strike Rec.24 to review team, and submit for approval on plenary call next week.

Calvin

 

 

COMPLETE
#36

Rec. 17, 18: Calvin to add success measures to recs 17, 18 and to circulate for plenary discussion next weekCalvin

 

 

COMPLETE
#35

 

Rec. 16: To be submitted on tomorrow's plenary call, and shared via email ahead of the plenary call.ICANN orgDec 6, 2017

 

COMPLETE
#35

Rec 24: Calvin to recirculate recommendation, including his concern that the recommendation and contract language might not be consistent.

Calvin

 

COMPLETE
#35


Rec. 13: Gao to reflect/redline latest updates to her assigned recommendation in a different color. More time will be provided to the subteam to review the recommendation.Gao

 

COMPLETE
#34

 

Rec 16:

  • Laureen/Carlos to change the rationale/related finding to add a reference to the DNS Abuse Study and the correlation between registration restriction and DNS Abuse.
  • On point (3) in recommendation, Laureen/Carlos to change that focus on whether registration restrictions "reduce" DNS Abuse. Add a reference that acknowledges Review Team already has a finding from the DNS Abuse study that registration restrictions decrease DNS Abuse.
Laureen/Carlos

 

 

COMPLETE
#33

 

Laureen to resend email including action items on draft report updates, which was sent out before ICANN60.

LaureenNov 15

 

COMPLETE
#33

 

Rec. 16Carlos & Laureen to refocus recommendation to focus on data collection needed for the next review team rather than a specific study. 

Carlos/LaureenNov 15

 

COMPLETE
#33

 

Rec 13, 15, 33: To be consolidated: 

  • Laureen to consider whether it will be a part of the earlier larger recommendation on conducting a single end- user survey.
  • Jordyn to consolidate registrant survey recommendations and Laureen to address end-user survey recommendations for possible consolidation. 
  • Laureen to figure out if 33 is consolidated or stands alone.

Laureen

Jordyn/Laureen

Laureen

Nov 15, 2017

 

COMPLETE
#33

 

Rec 14Jonathan, David and Carlos to confer on a recommendation to promote a diversity of business models for New gTLDs (monoculture antidote). It will ultimately result in a recommendation affecting Consumer Choice & Consumer Trust sections. Jamie to help on including rationale from rec 35, 36 in rec 14.

Jonathan/David/Carlos/JamieNov 15

 

COMPLETE
#33

Subteam members to be ready to contribute to document our response to public comments received.

S&T Subteam

 

COMPLETE
#33

 

Subteam members to add "Success Measures" and "Details" when missing in your assigned recommendation

S&T Subteam

 

 

COMPLETE
#32

Liaise with SSR2 representatives on Recommendation 3 & 4 of the DNS Abuse paperDavidSept 26
OVERDUE
#32


Confirm whether ICANN Compliance has statistics on DNS abuse and complaints filed and whether they are resolved with a take down or not.

ICANN orgSept 26

 

COMPLETE
#32

Share updated version of the DNS Abuse Study paper ahead of tomorrow’s plenary call.DrewSept 26

 

COMPLETE
#31

Provide an updated version including suggested edits on the call, and circulate it to ICANN orgDavidSept 19

 

COMPLETE
#31

Share David's updated version of the INTA Survey paper to the subteam indicating that there was provisional consensus on the call, and invite them for comments by today COB.ICANN orgSept 19

 

COMPLETE
#30

Rec 21, 22, 23 to be discussed further on the next subteam's call, meanwhile please address your comments to Carlton/Laureen via email

S&T SubteamSept 13

 

COMPLETE
#29

DNS Abuse Study Paper: All to send comments to Drew by Friday this week.S&T SubteamSept 1

 

COMPLETE
#29

DNS Abuse Study Paper: Drew to schedule a call with Jamie to discuss implementability of the second recommendation.DrewSept 5

 

COMPLETE
#29

Rec 25: All to share comments/edits with Laureen by Friday this week.S&T SubteamSept 1

 

COMPLETE
#29

Rec. 31, 32: Fabro to include summary of public comments received on these recommendations, and add a revised version of the rationale.

FabroSept 1

 

COMPLETE
#28

Circulate the latest draft report versionJean-BaptisteAug 17, 2017

 

COMPLETE
#28

Drew to share his input on consolidation of PICs recommendations by next week

DrewAug 23, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#28

 

Circulate an email with Safeguards subteam upcoming action items / Subteam members to circulate their revision ahead of each subteam calls to allow enough time for review team members to digest and prepare questions.Laureen/Subteam members

 

COMPLETE 
#27

 

Rec. 35, 36: Drew, Carlos, Laureen, Jamie to further work on revising these recommendations based on the exchange today.Drew, Carlos, Laureen, JamieAug 16, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#27

 

Rec. 16: Laureen to revise the text (add more specifity on what is needed - differentiate registrations restrictions and impact/effect ) and circulate it to the subteam.LaureenAug 16, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#27

 

Rec. 19 & 34: Drew will further refine these to ensure that we are clear about categorizing the types of restrictions we are talking about and the types of abuse we are talking about rather than registration restrictions and DNS abuse as two broad categories.DrewAug 16, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#25

 

6. DNS Abuse: Rec 19, 34 (Drew) - Consolidation conditionally approved. (same priority level: High)

7. Complaints: Rec. 21, 22, 23 (Carlton): Conditionally approved with High priority (different priority level rec.  23 = High, while other are Medium)

Other: Rec. 13, 15, 33 (Gao): No need for consolidation.


  • If you were unable to attend the call, please share your input on the above consolidation suggestion, and on the consolidations identified last week.
  • For leaders of consolidated recommendations, consider revision for all the corresponding text and weigh in the need to adapt the narratives.
ALLJul 26, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#24

 

Rec 10. (RPMs) David to look at the recommendation and consider whether that can be combined with recommendations 40 to 42.

Rec. 16: Laureen to look into possible consolidation with other recommendations linked to juridiction restrictions.

Rec 19, 34 (DNS Abuse Study) and 38, 39 (Pics): Drew to consolidate.

Rec 21.22.23 (Complaints Mechanisms): Laureen and Carlton to liaise together and review the proposed consolidation.

Rec 25-30 (Highly Regulated gTLDs): Laureen to review whether these can be consolidated. All to circulate to the group their suggestions for recommendations consolidation by Friday, this week. Wiki: Staff to build a dedicated page for draft report updates.

David

Laureen

Drew

Laureen/Carlton

Laureen

Jul 14, 2017

 

COMPLETE 
#23

 

Rec 14: Jonathan & Laureen to reformulate the recommendationJonathan/Laureen

 

COMPLETE 
#20

All to carefully review E Agopian email of 19 Sept 2016 on Nielsen paperAllASAP1COMPLETE 
#20

Jonathan Zuck to speak with Nielsen and analyze results; will present to team at next meetingJonathanOct 4/2016COMPLETE 
#20

Look for email update from Laureen, continue working on papers and getting team feedbackLaureenOngoingCOMPLETE
#19

Recirculate links that are relevant to Right Protection Mechanisms databases and to advise whether possible to indicate what nature of complaints was -https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/cct-metrics-compliance-2016-06-27-en.StaffASAPCOMPLETE
#19


 Send David comments on RPM related subquestions (if any)AllASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Read Trust in the domain name system paper. Carlos and Laureen to discuss whether follow-ups needed.All, Carlos, LaureenASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Add to consumer trust paper: perceived value in new innovations (registration restrictions, validation, voluntary PICs)Laureen, FabroASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Discuss how to incorporate implementation of innovations and initiativesLaureen, GaoASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Connect on consumer trust in the DNSJamie, LaureenASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Schedule two check-in times with their pair between 6 September and 15 SeptemberAllASAPCOMPLETE
#19


Identify for Alice whether working with traditional email or google doc.Lead DraftersASAP1COMPLETE
#19


Connect with Fabro to ensure aware of where data sources for safeguards live.Drew, StaffASAP1COMPLETE
#19

Look at compliance data that may be useful for DNS abuse complaints.Drew, CalvinASAP1COMPLETE
#18


Categorize public interest commitments by typeCarltonASAP OVERDUE
#18


Tie enforcement of specification 11 to risks intended to mitigate and to hold a call with subteamCarltonASAP OVERDUE
#18


Send additional sources of interest to staff for compilation on wiki pageDavidASAPCOMPLETE
#18


Put together a definition of DNS abuse based on safeguardsDrewASAPCOMPLETE
#18


Connect on anti-counterfeitCarlton, DrewASAPCOMPLETE
#18


Hold a call with ICANN complianceFabro, Calvin, CarltonASAPCOMPLETE
#18


consolidate compliance related data request. Important to check if available in existing resources.Fabro, CalvinASAP1COMPLETE
#18

Share Department of Commerce's Consumer Study with TeamDrewASAP1COMPLETE
#17

Laureen and Calvin to connect on Technical Safeguards

Laureen, CalvinASAP1COMPLETE
#17

All leads to engage team members for presentation in Vienna - no "lead only" presentationsAllASAP1COMPLETE
#17

Ping David and make sure he is engaged in his topics

LaureenASAPCOMPLETE 
#17

Jamie to connect with his sub team members to ensure he is engaged on best topicsJamieASAPCOMPLETE
#17

Carlos continue work on discussion paper 5 - Laureen to send further feedbackCarlos, LaureenASAPCOMPLETE 
#17

Carlos to connect with Drew on paper 6

Carlos, DrewASAPCOMPLETE 
#17

Gao to connect with her sub team to ensure engagement

GaoASAPCOMPLETE 
#17

Fabro to connect with David

Fabro, DavidASAPCOMPLETE 
#17

All team members to take a big picture look at discussion topics and see if some can be consolidated, or if there are any missing topicsAllASAPCOMPLETE 
#16

Put together inventory of universe of data available to Team and include inventory of what is pendingAllASAP1COMPLETE 
#16

Refine template sections/nomenclatureJonathanASAP/CLOSED
#16

Add GAC communiqués starting from Beijing to impact of safeguards resources page StaffASAP1COMPLETE
#16

Send Laureen recap of metrics/resources linksAliceASAP1COMPLETE
#16

 

Create a sample discussion paper on trust issues for Team members to use as a referenceLaureenASAP1COMPLETE
#15

 

 Start filling in documents without waiting for Team membersDrew, Laureen, Fabro, David, Carlton (leads)ASAPCOMPLETE 
#15

 

Populate google-sheet with initial findings based on sourcesAllASAP1COMPLETE 
#15

 

Circulate any last minute comments/edits on DNS Abuse Research PlanAll07/29/20161COMPLETE
/

 

Complete discussion papersAll (details here)08/20/20161COMPLETE 
/

 

Review discussion paper assignments and indicate if any changes neededAll07/22/2016COMPLETE
#14

 

Review and suggest edits/additions to Drew's suggested voluntary PICs questionsAll07/14/20160OVERDUE
#14

 

Provide feedback on the Discussion Papers Topic List and indicate which paper you want to writeAll07/14/20160OVERDUE
#14

 

Insert analysis of Right Protections Mechanisms safeguards in gdocDavid, JamieASAP1COMPLETE 
#14

 

Review Laureen's input on Spec 11/GAC advice safeguards in gdoc and add (as needed)Carlton, CarlosASAPCOMPLETE 
#14

 

Review Drew's input on Technical category/DNS abuse in gdoc and add (as needed)Calvin, Fabro, GaoASAPCOMPLETE
#14

 

In g-doc finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory) and mark in green if useful

Drew, Calvin, Fabro, CarltonASAPCOMPLETE
#14

 

In g-doc finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory) and mark in green if useful

Drew, Calvin, Gao, Carlton, David, Jamie, Laureen, Fabro

ASAPCOMPLETE
#14

 

In g-doc finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory) and mark in green if useful

Laureen, Gao, CarltonASAPCOMPLETE
#14

 

In g-doc finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory) and mark in green if useful.

David, JamieASAP 1COMPLETE
#13

 

Review Safeguards table and advise whether any additional data is neededAll07/15/2016COMPLETE
#13

 

Report to Drew on completion of analysis of sources (g-doc)Fabro, Carlton, David07/12/20160OVERDUE
#13

 

Work with Drew to finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory)Calvin, Fabro, Carlton07/12/20160OVERDUE
#13

 

Work with Fabro to finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory)Drew, Calvin, Gao, Carlton, David, Jamie, Laureen07/12/20160OVERDUE
#13

 

Work with Carlton to finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory)Laureen, Gao07/12/20160OVERDUE
#13

 

Work with David to finalize analysis of your assigned sources (inventory)Jamie07/12/20160OVERDUE
#13

 

Reach out to David Conrad to schedule a call on benefits of DNSSEC in new gTLD programJamieASAP1COMPLETE
#12

 

Complete analysis of findingsAllASAP0.5PARTIALLY COMPLETE
#12

 

Set up a meeting with ICANN compliance to determine whether data already collected is available for a comparisonStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#12

 

Send list of ICANN 57 sessions of interestStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#11

 

Reach to subteam members to divide work on safeguards analysisAllASAP0OVERDUE
#11

 

Clarify headings of findings template and circulate an exampleLaureenASAP1COMPLETE
#11

 

Add background resources sections on wiki page and include WHOIS docsStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#10

 

Produce revised work planStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#10

 

In g-doc finalize analysis of your respective assignments and highlight useful resourcesAllASAP0.5PARTIALLY COMPLETE
#10

 

Produce analysis of SSAC papersCarlton - CarlosASAP0OVERDUE
#10

 

Populate safeguards analysis chart (g-doc)All06/21/20160.5PARTIALLY COMPLETE
#9

 

Determine which reading list items they would like to volunteer for and to notify LaureenAllASAP0.5PARTIALLY COMPLETE
#9

 

Discuss vendor options with security team

Margie, Eleeza, Drew, Laureen, BrianASAP1COMPLETE
#8

 

Provide additional data on DNS Abuse related safeguardsStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#8

 

Circulate PICs research proposalStaffASAP1COMPLETE
#7

 

Review list of what gTLD strings have and have not been delegated (ICANN chart)StaffASAP1COMPLETE
#6

 

Review navigation and use issues for Consumer End User discussion and circulate to the teamCarlosASAP1 COMPLETE

...