Zoom chat: 2020-09-14 NARALO Teleconference

13:59:04 From Adrian Schmidt : Hello! Happy Monday!!!
13:59:29 From Glenn McKnight : Hi all
13:59:33 From Silvia Vivanco : Hello everyone
13:59:35 From Silvia Vivanco : Welcome
14:01:24 From herb waye ombuds : Greetings everyone, nice to see names and hear voices. Hope everyone is safe and healthy.
14:01:53 From David Mackey : Hi Herb, safe and sound here in Canada. :-)
14:02:21 From Heidi Ullrich : Welcome, All.
14:02:34 From Chris Mondini : Nice to see you Herb - I echo your sentiments!
14:02:50 From Silvia Vivanco : Warm welcome to Chris and Herb
14:03:08 From Bill Jouris : Safe, but definitely doing shallow breathing in California
14:03:31 From David Mackey : @Bill Take care, eh!
14:03:47 From Yubelkys Montalvo : greetings to all!
14:04:08 From Bill Jouris : Fortunately, covid means we all have masks already to hand
14:04:08 From Javier Rúa-Jovet : Hello to all; excuse tardiness.
14:04:31 From Maureen Hilyard : +1 Eduardo
14:04:31 From Silvia Vivanco : Welcome all
14:05:26 From Marita Moll : Right Judith -- thanks for bringing this up.
14:06:17 From Marita Moll : We want to encourage folks to attend the operations and finance meetings as well. They usually happen once per month
14:07:11 From Heidi Ullrich : The OFB-WG is at : https://community.icann.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=132940946
14:07:12 From Maureen Hilyard : CPWG and the OFBWG are the key At-Large discussion groups
14:07:32 From Glenn McKnight : Our Sept and Nov VSIG is full, 200 students. March and Jan is open registration
14:07:59 From David Mackey : post-mortem phase 1?
14:08:11 From Glenn McKnight : Raising the dead
14:08:14 From Javier Rúa-Jovet : Post mortem on the living dead.
14:08:26 From David Mackey : @Javier lol
14:09:11 From Marita Moll : Congrats Glenn & Alfredo on that many registrations for the first term
14:09:34 From Glenn McKnight : Thanks Marita
14:09:50 From David Mackey : +1 Marita
14:10:25 From Marita Moll : Virtual champagne for the grand opening?
14:14:24 From Wes Boudville : what's the difference between a Registrar & a Registry?
14:15:17 From David Mackey : @Wes fyi: https://ca.godaddy.com/help/what-is-the-difference-between-a-registry-registrar-and-registrant-8039
14:15:32 From Wes Boudville : thanks! DAvid
14:16:05 From David Mackey : TLDR: Registrars are resellers of TLDs
14:17:01 From leahsymekher : Hi All, Leah here…sorry bit late for this meeting
14:18:54 From Silvia Vivanco : @Wes, you may find this website with names and descriptions of ICANN’s acronyms useful: https://www.icann.org/icann-acronyms-and-terms/en/nav/R
14:31:03 From Alfredo Calderon : <Question>What is the main deadlock between ‘Legal’ versus ‘Natural’? Is it because a legal person could also be a natural person? <Question>
14:35:59 From Alfredo Calderon : <Question>Could ICANN become “the Controller” if a mandate is given by it’s constituencies? Has that been considered? <Question>
14:38:17 From Wes Boudville : Did the groups do all their work in English? Were translators used ?
14:38:47 From Bill Jouris : @Alfredo, if the contracted parties, as Alan says, insist that they are the Controller, then ICANN cannot achieve consensus that it is the Controller. Because the largest stakeholder (based on Board membership, not to mention membership on this WG) disagrees
14:39:14 From Alfredo Calderon : @Bill, thanks.
14:39:38 From David Mackey : <Question> Is there an economic advantage to the contracted parties to use the controlled data for marketing purposes? The business advantage might justify the liability of being a controller.
14:39:52 From Alfredo Calderon : Thanks @Bill, that is actually what I thought.
14:40:49 From Javier Rúa-Jovet : Privacy is a human right!
14:45:48 From Alfredo Calderon : Adopted version for public consultation 1 Guidelines 07/2020 on the concepts of controller and processor in the GDPR — https://edpb.europa.eu/sites/edpb/files/consultation/edpb_guidelines_202007_controllerprocessor_en.pdf
14:50:02 From Yubelkys Montalvo : thanks for the presentation!
14:53:39 From David Mackey : +1 Alan
14:54:11 From Loris Taylor : Great presentation Alan! Privacy is definitely a public interest. Thank you.
14:54:24 From Javier Rúa-Jovet : 10-4 @Alan
14:54:36 From Yubelkys Montalvo : very clear and pertinent!
14:55:06 From leahsymekher : Thank you Alan. very helpful summary.
14:55:13 From Marita Moll : And there are hardly words enough to recognize the work that Alan and Hadia have put in
14:55:19 From Javier Rúa-Jovet : Thxxx
14:55:26 From Alfredo Calderon : Thank you @Alan.
14:55:50 From Chris Mondini : Indeed. +1 Judith
14:55:54 From David Mackey : +1 Judith
14:55:56 From Heidi Ullrich : +1 Judith
14:56:08 From Heidi Ullrich : And the weekly updates on the CP’WG
14:56:11 From Michelle DeSmyter : To participate in the survey, please go to this link and fill out: https://forms.gle/ADQiQg1V8J3KRGSW8
14:56:12 From Glenn McKnight : Thanks helpful to understand the process and the history
14:56:12 From Maureen Hilyard : Thanks Alan for this interesting presentation
14:56:24 From Michelle DeSmyter : https://forms.gle/ADQiQg1V8J3KRGSW8
14:57:40 From Silvia Vivanco : Please kindly complete the questions on the google form above
14:58:35 From Silvia Vivanco : Your feedback will be used for metrics and to determine your interest for topics for the next webinars
14:58:36 From David Mackey : I completed the form. Thanks again Eduardo for the format of the monthly NARALO meeting. Bye All!
14:58:46 From Silvia Vivanco : Thank you David
14:59:28 From Alfredo Calderon : Stay well and safe! Completed the Survey.
14:59:47 From Silvia Vivanco : Thank you all for your participation and filling out the survey
15:00:19 From Silvia Vivanco : Excellent topic @ Jonathan
15:00:46 From Marita Moll : I haven't seen it advertised but that would be great
15:01:05 From Jonathan Zuck : OH whew! Thanks Alfredo
15:01:46 From leahsymekher : thank Jonathan that will be helpful
15:02:09 From Yubelkys Montalvo : Have a wonderful day and stay safe!
15:02:12 From Silvia Vivanco : Thank you all for your participation
15:02:14 From Marita Moll : Co-vid disconnection with time, Eduardo
15:02:17 From Michelle DeSmyter : At-Large Capacity Building Webinar Monday, 21 September at 13:00 UTC
15:02:25 From herb waye ombuds : take care all
15:02:29 From Marita Moll : Bye all
15:02:31 From Yubelkys Montalvo : bye