The call for the New gTLD Subsequent Procedures Sub Group B will take place on Tuesday, 05 March 2019 at 17:00 UTC for 60 minutes.

09:00 PST, 12:00 EST, 18:00 Paris CET, 22:00 Karachi PKT, (Wednesday) 02:00 Tokyo JST, (Wednesday) 04:00 Melbourne AEDT

For other times: https://tinyurl.com/y4o7z723

PROPOSED AGENDA


Agenda

1.  Welcome and Review of Agenda

2.  Updates to Statements of Interest (SOI’s)

4.   Discussion of Public Comments on 2.7.8 Name Collisions

5.  AOB

The Google document can be found at: 

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/133WbhWYB4M4kT6DqSfiCR2-ij7jxNkLj5EWZL-NA95M/edit?usp=sharing [docs.google.com]

 

 BACKGROUND DOCUMENTS



RECORDINGS


Mp3

Adobe connect recording

GNSO transcripts are located on the GNSO Calendar

PARTICIPATION


Attendance & AC chat

Apologies: Jim Prendergast, Justine Chew

Notes/ Action Items


Actions:

 

ACTION ITEM 1: General Comments: Ask Justine if the ALAC comment means "wait for SSAC public comment recommendations" or "wait for SSAC NCAP study recommendations".

 

Notes:

 

1.  Updates to Statements of Interest (SOI’s):  No updates provided.

 

2.   Discussion of Public Comments on 2.7.8 Name Collisions:

 

General Comments:

Line 4, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

Anne Aikman-Scalese: Per Dennis Chang, the Board has had questions about the cost of the NCAP. I'm not sure what Rubens means by "on hold".  So maybe we should ask Rubens?  I think the ALAC comment relates to waiting for the NCAP to complete, but Justine could clarify.

 

Line 5, ICANN Org -- [comment: that SAC045 recommendations are in the AGB]

Line 6, XYZ -- Concerns

Line 7, SSAC -- [SAC090 recommendations]

 

2.7.8.c.1:

Lines 10-12, Brand Registry Group, Valideus, IPC -- Agreement

Line 13, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 14, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 15, ALAC -- Divergence

 

2.7.8.c.2:

Line 17, BRG -- Agreement

Line 18, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 19, RySG -- [questions]

Line 20, IPC -- [comment -- defer to NCAP]

Line 21, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.3:

Line 23, BRG -- Agreement

Line 24, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 25, RySG -- Agreement (qualified)

Line 26, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 27, RySG -- Agreement (with questions) Divergence

Line 28, IPC -- Divergence (defer to NCAP)

Line 29, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.4:

Line 31, BRG -- Agreement

Line 32, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 33, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 34, RySG -- [questions]

Line 35, IPC -- Divergence (refer to NCAP)

Line 36, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.5:

Line 38, BRG -- Agreement

Line 39, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 40, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 41, RySG -- Agreement Concerns (with questions)

Line 42, IPC -- Divergence (defer to NCAP)

Line 43, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.6:

Line 45, BRG -- Agreement

Line 46, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 47, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 48, RySG -- [questions]

Line 49, IPC -- Divergence

Line 50, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.7:

Line 52, BRG -- Agreement

Line 53, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Lines 54-55, RySG & IPC -- Agreement (qualified)

Line 56, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.8:

Line 58, BRG -- Agreement

Line 59, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 60, RySG -- [questions]

Line 61, IPC -- Agreement Divergence

Line 62, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.9:

Line 64, BRG -- Agreement

Line 65, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations) New Idea

Line 66, Neustar -- Divergence

Line 67, RySG -- Divergence

Line 68, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.c.10:

Lines 70 & 71, BRG & RySG -- Agreement

Line 72, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.1:

Line 74, ICANN Board -- [answered the question -- could combine work]

Line 75, Neustar -- [answered the question - don't delay for NCAP]

Line 76, USPS -- [answered the question - defer to NCAP]

Line 77, RySG -- [answered the question - agees there are dependencies, but differing positions]

Line 78, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.2:

Line 80, RrSG -- Agreement (support for current mitigation frameworks)

Line 81, Neustar -- Agreement (support for current mitigation frameworks)

Line 82, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 83, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.3:

Lines 85 & 86, RrSG and Neustar -- Agreement (support 90-day period or reduce)

Line 87, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 88, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.4:

Line 90, RySG -- [answered the question -- defer to SSAC]

Line 91, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.5:

Line 93, Neustar -- Divergence

Line 94, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 95, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.6:

Line 97, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 98, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.7:

Line 100, Ming.LTD Group -- Out of PDP Scope; possible referral to NCAP, if it ever restarts

Line 101, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 102, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

2.7.8.e.8:

Line 104, RySG -- [answered the question -- offers two viewpoints]

Line 105, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

 

  • No labels