Mario Aleman:Welcome to the NARALO Special Purpose Call on NARALO Elections 2017: "Get to know the candidates" on Wednesday, 17 May 2017 at 21:00 UTC
Seth Reiss:Can I test my mic?
Mario Aleman:Welcome Seth, I can hear you ok
Seth Reiss:good thanks
Mario Aleman:Hello Glenn, welcome to the call
Glenn McKnight:Hi Seth, Mario and Gisella
Glenn McKnight:I will phone in so you don't hear me typing
Mario Aleman:ok
Mario Aleman:Nobody has requested dial out so far. Let us know if you have any request
Glenn McKnight:sound check
Seth Reiss:Glenn, I need to leave punctually at one hour in because I have a plane to catch.
Seth Reiss:Mahalo
Seth Reiss:I di dnot hear Leah
Seth Reiss:I hear you now!
Seth Reiss:where are the questions?
Mario Aleman:Sure
Glenn McKnight:https://community.icann.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=64950280
Seth Reiss:Got it
Javier Rúa-Jovet:hey!
Gordon Chillcott:Been there. Done that. Hated it
Silvia Vivanco:Hello all
Silvia Vivanco:welcome
Silvia Vivanco:we are still gathering
John Laprise 2:I'm having microphone issues
Javier Rúa-Jovet:I'll be here without mic. I'm driving and I'm on my cellphone
Gordon Chillcott:Yep
John Laprise 2:I can hear just fine
Mario Aleman:Do you need a call, John?
John Laprise 2:I've had a problem since adobe changed to flash
Heidi Ullrich:Hi All, Welcome!
Louis Houle:Hello everyone
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Greetings from Sunny San Francsico. Hope you're all well :)
judith hellerstein:Greetings from Rainy Saint Paul
judith hellerstein:just finished the excellent National Digital Inclusion Conference
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Susannah
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter)::)
John Laprise:I still have no mike
judith hellerstein:They are giving you a call out on your cell. I believe
judith hellerstein:Did you send them your phone number?
Alan Greenberg:I am still on another call. for about 10-12 more minutes. Will be here as soon as possible.
Glenn McKnight:ok
Glenn McKnight:John please verify that you got the phone call from staff
judith hellerstein:Mario you are breaking up a bit
Eve Edelson:hello all
judith hellerstein:Do we have quorom on the call?
Silvia Vivanco:https://community.icann.org/display/NARALO/NARALO+2017+Elections
judith hellerstein:NOt people but ALSes
Tom Lowenhaupt:Why do we need a quorm?
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Leah, Susannah, Eve = SF Bay Chapter.
judith hellerstein:We can leave this for the end
Silvia Vivanco:19 participants
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):We are a three-headed beast.
Tom Lowenhaupt:Why do we need quorm?
Eve Edelson::)
Yubelkys:hello to all
Tom Lowenhaupt:No decisions today.
John More:Why does there have to be a quorum for a candidates call. No actions will be taken.
Silvia Vivanco:we will call for rough consensus
judith hellerstein:@john we are doing rough consensus for the 2 positions that are not contested
John Laprise:i'm dialed in
judith hellerstein:This way we do not have to send an email and get rough consensus
John More:The email that went out did not speak of there being a vote today consensus or otherwise.
Glenn McKnight:@Leah, Eva and Susannah please cast one vote during the rough consensus voting
Heidi Ullrich:Glenn's note about this call stated: The two issues for the call is confirmation by rough consensus on the uncontested positions of chair and secretariat and also a Q and A session called Meet the Candidates on the contested positions for ALAC and NOMCOM
Glenn McKnight:no vote but rough consensus on the Chair and Secetariat
John More:Ok. Missed that.
Glenn McKnight:getting the temperature of the room on the two uncontested positions
Glenn McKnight:Silvia will ask the ALS
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Leah, as the offical listed contact, will vote.
Javier Rúa-Jovet:I agree with both
judith hellerstein:for ISOC DC I think Dustin is the assigned rep for voting
John More:I agree with both.
John More:I see no check marks.
Glenn McKnight:up on the top bar
judith hellerstein:It is the icon next to the muyte button
Eve Edelson:yes
Eve Edelson:yes I hear you
John Laprise:ty eve
Eve Edelson:yes i hear you
Javier Rúa-Jovet:I agree with eduardo and Glenn
Javier Rúa-Jovet:I just found the checkmark in my phone
Yubelkys:me too
judith hellerstein:do we have quorum to say this?
Glenn McKnight:thanks for the vote of confidence
Javier Rúa-Jovet:yayyyy
Yubelkys:I agree too
Yubelkys:I'm in my car
Alan Greenberg:On audio bridge now.
Silvia Vivanco:so we have 11 votes out of 19 attendees
Silvia Vivanco:at this call
Silvia Vivanco:to define rough consensus
judith hellerstein:I believe that Javier is an individual candidate
judith hellerstein:Yubelkys also voted yes but was on audio
judith hellerstein:congrats to Eduardo and Glenn
Louis Houle:Great! Congrats.
Heidi Ullrich:Congratulions to Eduardo and Glenn!!!
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):When is the AGM - Silvia broke up
Javier Rúa-Jovet:congrats!!
judith hellerstein:In October at teh Abu Dhabi meeting
Glenn McKnight:my pleasure
Eve Edelson:I hear you
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):TY Judith
Silvia Vivanco:Annual General Meeting is at the fall meeting 28 Oct - 3 November 2017
Yubelkys:congrats Eduardo
Silvia Vivanco:Congratulations to both Eduardo and Glenn
Silvia Vivanco:on their positions
Yubelkys:Glenn ð
Yubelkys:congratulations ð
Glenn McKnight:Opening Statements John Laprise 2 minutes
Glenn McKnight:Mario will be taking the time
Glenn McKnight:Please indicate the 10 second warning
Glenn McKnight:Seth you will be next for 2 minutes
Glenn McKnight:Leah you will be next for 2 minutes
Yubelkys:hi Seth
Silvia Vivanco:You can see the candidates SOIs linked to the Election page
Seth Reiss:@yubelkys - Hi
Tom Lowenhaupt:My question: Today's New York Times has a story "Vulnerable Voices" Lash Out as Companies Sway Climate Talks. It talks about how 300 industry groups are free to roam the negotiations in Bonn's climate change negotiations as stakeholders. The story details objections being raised about undue influence to undue corporate influence by various nations. The "climate" at ICANN is very different. Not only do the companies participate as stakeholders, they have voting majorities. It wasn't supposed to be that way at the start of ICANN - the users had a majority in early iterations. How can we move toward user majorities on the ICANN board. How can we assure that NOMCOM nominees are committed to control by individual internet users of ICANN governance processes?
Glenn McKnight:Judith you will be next for two minutes
Glenn McKnight:@Tom who is this question for ALAC or NOMCOM or everyone
Mario Aleman:10 minutes left
Mario Aleman:seconds
Mario Aleman:sorry^
Silvia Vivanco:thank you Mario
Silvia Vivanco:time is up
judith hellerstein:I had finished
Tom Lowenhaupt:Nomcom is more important.
Silvia Vivanco:Thank you for that statement Judith
Glenn McKnight:I apologize to all for cutting you off. Mario please make it clear to all when time is running low
Glenn McKnight:time left?
Mario Aleman:40 secs
Glenn McKnight:thanks
Mario Aleman:10 seconds
Glenn McKnight:Thanks Siliva please just interject
Silvia Vivanco:ok
Mario Aleman:1 minute left
Glenn McKnight:Thanks Mario
Mario Aleman:No problem
Mario Aleman:1 minute left
Silvia Vivanco:Open questions now
Tom Lowenhaupt:Nomcom
Seth Reiss:I think I did not get to answer your second question Glenn?
Silvia Vivanco:for anyone who would like to ask a quesiton
Glenn McKnight:Sorry folks, can you please put the questions in the centre panel. i am going back and forth
Glenn McKnight:in different screens
Mario Aleman:1 minute left on the answer
Glenn McKnight:the pictures were for the opening statements
Tom Lowenhaupt:NARALO candidates should address the question.
Glenn McKnight:Tom for ALAC or NOMCOM?
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Apologies for dog barking in background.
Glenn McKnight:TIme tracking on this question?
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):thank you John.
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Thanks Seth.
Glenn McKnight:Please indicate the time progression
Mario Aleman:1:10 left
Glenn McKnight:time left?
Mario Aleman:1 minute
Glenn McKnight:thanks
Mario Aleman:20 seconds
Mario Aleman:1:20 left
Glenn McKnight:time
Glenn McKnight:?
Mario Aleman:45 seconds
Glenn McKnight:k
Mario Aleman:15 seconds
Mario Aleman:Time is up!
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Great question
Tom Lowenhaupt:IS my question to be addressed?
Glenn McKnight:Yes next after Judith finishes responded.
Glenn McKnight:Tom do you have voice
Glenn McKnight:Tom can you ask the question?
Mario Aleman:1 minute
Javier Rúa-Jovet:thank you both!
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Glenn, if time allows I have a general question to you. If not, I will ask it on skype later.
Tom Lowenhaupt:Not sure the audio
Tom Lowenhaupt:no audio
Tom Lowenhaupt:NOMCOM
Javier Rúa-Jovet:that is a great question
Louis Houle:Indeed
Mario Aleman:1:00 left
Glenn McKnight:I directed to Judith and Leah
Glenn McKnight:time left?
Mario Aleman:40 secods
Glenn McKnight:time
Mario Aleman:1 minute
Glenn McKnight:please let her know when is close to the end
Louis Houle:ALAC candidate question Glenn?
Glenn McKnight:sorry we don't have time for more questions
Mario Aleman:30 seconds
Glenn McKnight:only closing statements
Glenn McKnight:Mario interject at 10 seconds left
Mario Aleman:30 seconds
Glenn McKnight:You need to to tell them
Glenn McKnight:thanks
Javier Rúa-Jovet:a bit!!!!???
Louis Houle:ALAC candidates: how can you act to improve ALAC notoriety and make sure that ICANN is taking more seriously ALAC advice and recommandations on policies?
judith hellerstein:I think it was from mario when he was going off and on
Mario Aleman:yes
Glenn McKnight:need 10 second warning
Mario Aleman:We can use a time on the main screen
Silvia Vivanco:but the timer would take up the entire screen
Glenn McKnight:its been a challenge
Glenn McKnight:It's tough to be a time keeper
Mario Aleman:15 seconds
Glenn McKnight:Mario time?
Javier Rúa-Jovet:+1 Louis' question: How do we (ALAC) get some respect?? (And food and coffee in our meeting rooms, like GAC!!!)
Seth Reiss:Gotta to run to the airport. Thank you all.
Louis Houle:No problem!
Yubelkys:safe flight
Seth Reiss:Mahalo
Glenn McKnight:safe flight Seth
Heidi Ullrich:Thanks, everyone!
Glenn McKnight:Thanks all
Javier Rúa-Jovet:safe travels!!
Glenn McKnight:Election will be held please post the dates Mario
Yubelkys:thanks. excellent presentations!
Heidi Ullrich:The wiki page has been updated for the Chair and Secretary positions.
Glenn McKnight:March 22 to March 26
Louis Houle:I also have an additional question for our NomCom candidate, but slightly different.
Yubelkys:ok
Tom Lowenhaupt:bye
judith hellerstein:Louis happy to answer them at anytime
Silvia Vivanco:So stay tuned for elections May 22- 26
Yubelkys:thank to all. Have an nice evening!
Susannah Gray (SF Bay ISOC Chapter):Thank you all.
Javier Rúa-Jovet:thanx to all! bye!
Tom Lowenhaupt:Great squeezing of info into short time period.
Eve Edelson:bye all
Louis Houle:Thanks to the candidates! Good luck
Gordon Chillcott:Thanks and bye for now\
Louis Houle:Bye
Yubelkys:bye