Page History

Mp3

Adobe connect recording

GNSO transcripts are located on the GNSO Calendar

Notes/ Action Items

Actions:

ACTION ITEM 1: General Comments: Ask Justine if the ALAC comment means "wait for SSAC public comment recommendations" or "wait for SSAC NCAP study recommendations".

Notes:

1.  Updates to Statements of Interest (SOI’s):  No updates provided.

2.   Discussion of Public Comments on 2.7.8 Name Collisions:

General Comments:

Line 4, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

Anne Aikman-Scalese: Per Dennis Chang, the Board has had questions about the cost of the NCAP. I'm not sure what Rubens means by "on hold".  So maybe we should ask Rubens?  I think the ALAC comment relates to waiting for the NCAP to complete, but Justine could clarify.

Line 5, ICANN Org -- [comment: that SAC045 recommendations are in the AGB]

Line 6, XYZ -- Concerns

Line 7, SSAC -- [SAC090 recommendations]

2.7.8.c.1:

Lines 10-12, Brand Registry Group, Valideus, IPC -- Agreement

Line 13, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 14, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 15, ALAC -- Divergence

2.7.8.c.2:

Line 17, BRG -- Agreement

Line 18, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 19, RySG -- [questions]

Line 20, IPC -- [comment -- defer to NCAP]

Line 21, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.3:

Line 23, BRG -- Agreement

Line 24, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 25, RySG -- Agreement (qualified)

Line 26, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 27, RySG -- Agreement (with questions) Divergence

Line 28, IPC -- Divergence (defer to NCAP)

Line 29, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.4:

Line 31, BRG -- Agreement

Line 32, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 33, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 34, RySG -- [questions]

Line 35, IPC -- Divergence (refer to NCAP)

Line 36, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.5:

Line 38, BRG -- Agreement

Line 39, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 40, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 41, RySG -- Agreement Concerns (with questions)

Line 42, IPC -- Divergence (defer to NCAP)

Line 43, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.6:

Line 45, BRG -- Agreement

Line 46, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 47, Neustar -- Agreement Concerns

Line 48, RySG -- [questions]

Line 49, IPC -- Divergence

Line 50, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.7:

Line 52, BRG -- Agreement

Line 53, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Lines 54-55, RySG & IPC -- Agreement (qualified)

Line 56, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.8:

Line 58, BRG -- Agreement

Line 59, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations)

Line 60, RySG -- [questions]

Line 61, IPC -- Agreement Divergence

Line 62, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.9:

Line 64, BRG -- Agreement

Line 65, ICANN Org -- Agreement (qualified -- operational considerations) New Idea

Line 66, Neustar -- Divergence

Line 67, RySG -- Divergence

Line 68, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.c.10:

Lines 70 & 71, BRG & RySG -- Agreement

Line 72, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.1:

Line 74, ICANN Board -- [answered the question -- could combine work]

Line 75, Neustar -- [answered the question - don't delay for NCAP]

Line 76, USPS -- [answered the question - defer to NCAP]

Line 77, RySG -- [answered the question - agees there are dependencies, but differing positions]

Line 78, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.2:

Line 80, RrSG -- Agreement (support for current mitigation frameworks)

Line 81, Neustar -- Agreement (support for current mitigation frameworks)

Line 82, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 83, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.3:

Lines 85 & 86, RrSG and Neustar -- Agreement (support 90-day period or reduce)

Line 87, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 88, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.4:

Line 90, RySG -- [answered the question -- defer to SSAC]

Line 91, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.5:

Line 93, Neustar -- Divergence

Line 94, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 95, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.6:

Line 97, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 98, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.7:

Line 100, Ming.LTD Group -- Out of PDP Scope; possible referral to NCAP, if it ever restarts

Line 101, RySG -- Agreement Divergence

Line 102, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]

2.7.8.e.8:

Line 104, RySG -- [answered the question -- offers two viewpoints]

Line 105, ALAC -- [overview -- "wait on SSAC recommendations"]