AT-LARGE GATEWAY
At-Large Regional Policy Engagement Program (ARPEP)
At-Large Review Implementation Plan Development
Page History
Important Information Links | |
Comment Open: | 6 January 2012 |
Comment Close: | 23 March 2012 |
Close Time (UTC): | 23:59 UTC |
Reply Open: | 24 March 2012 |
Reply Close: | 13 April 2012 |
Close Time (UTC): | 23:59 UTC |
Brief Overview |
|
Originating Organization: | Joint ccNSO and GNSO IDN Working Group (JIG WG) |
Categories/Tags: |
|
Purpose (Brief): | The Initial Report reflects the preliminary stocktaking by the WG members of policy and other considerations relating to the Universal Acceptance of IDN TLDs. |
Current Status: | Seeking public comment on its Initial Report is part of the process to report on identified issues to the respective Councils and propose a methodology to address the issues. |
Next Steps: | The WG will closely review all submitted comments to revise and assess its preliminary stocktaking. |
Staff Contact: | Bart Boswinkel |
Email: |
...
Solutions are not always technical
Whilst the ICANN by its very nature is a type of multi stakeholder technical coordination body, it tends to seek comments and rely on comments from the technical community. The ALAC in a 2010 Statement is on record to say that not every problem has a technical solution and that ICANN should not deter from making a policy decision even when technical solutions do not exist\[[1]\[At-Large Policy Development Early Engagement: Locking of a Domain Name subject to UDRP Proceedings Workspace - May 2013|#_ftn1\]. An illustration to from a previous statement is as follows\[[2]\ An illustration to from a previous statement is as follows[2|#_ftn2\]:\- Wiki Markup
The Chinese SC-TC problem is a classic case. During the early days of IDN, it was proposed that SC-TC be handle within the IDN protocol. There was a long debate among the IETF Working Group participants and a strong push from the Chinese technical community.
...
ALAC would like to encourage ICANN to prioritize its efforts and exert its influence to best promoting Universal Acceptance and thanks the JIG for the initial report.
...
\[[1]\[At-Large Policy Development Early Engagement: Locking of a Domain Name subject to UDRP Proceedings Workspace - May 2013|#_ftnref1\] [ https://community.icann.org/display/alacidnpolicy/ALAC+Statement+IDN+Issues] Wiki Markup
\[[2]\|#_ftnref2\] ibid Wiki Markup