Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Item #SourceDateDecision reached
8#86

 

Recommendation 12 (budget and staffing resources) is considered complete, noting the role outlined in the Standing Committee charter to represent NomCom interests and resource needs in the annual planning and budgeting cycle, in addition to the NomCom, which can also weigh in on planning and budgeting.

7#86

 

Recommendation 11 (staff reporting) is considered complete, noting that NomCom support staff report to the Office of the CEO (per the meeting with ICANN’s CEO).

6#84

 

Approved to send the Executive Summary (as Progress Report #3) to the OEC. (completed)
5#75

 

RIWG agreed to develop a 1-page document to highlight its past and current work, as well as plans going forward, in preparation for the discussion with the OEC on 22 April 2021.
4#74

 

Rec. 1: Job Description. Working group agreed with NomCom Support Staff suggested approach:

  1. This year | Current Bylaws: Modify the draft NomCom job description to reflect the current Bylaws - NomCom Operations Team to distribute and be able to implement this recommendation this year.
  2. Going forward | Revised Bylaws: Revise the NomCom job description when the Bylaws have been revised - NomCom Operations Team to implement going forward
3#74

 

(In process) Rec. 13: Process map. Suggestion to recommend that the Standing Committee writes down in a separate document (than operating procedures) the business processes
2#74

 

(In process) Rec. 13: Process map. Only the developed baseline process map will be used for this recommendations, multiple process maps are no longer needed. Baseline process map will be updated later on in the implementation process, to reflect the outcome of some recommendations.
1#74

 

Future webinars: Keep using temperature questions (aka zoom room poll).

...

Item #Source of RequestDate of RequestAction Item RequestAction OwnerAnticipated Completion Date
109#86

 

Discussion on Recommendation 23 (candidate pool data) is tabled for the next RIWG meeting on 23 September.

NomCom Support Staff

 

108#85

 

ICANN org to work with Policy Support staff to determine a time for this meeting.  (facilitated by ICANN Org)

NomCom Support Staff
107#85

 

Draft SC charter decision-making process (facilitated by ICANN Org)

NomCom Support Staff
106#85

 

Summarize SC actions/roles from implementation steps to cross-reference with the final draft SC charter (facilitated by NomComRIWG & ICANN Org)

RIWG & NomCom Support Staff
105#85

 

Draft RIWG candidate pool metrics (facilitated by ICANN Org)

NomCom Support Staff

 

104#85

 

Agreed evaluation metrics document (facilitated NomComRIWG & ICANN Org)

NomCom Support Staff

 

103#84

 

Draft - guide for metrics. 

NomCom Support Staff

 

102#84

 

Recruitment firm project/process. 

NomCom Support Staff

 

101#82

 

Semi-annual update being prepared for 29th meeting  - Executive Summary to serve as Progress Report #3.

ICANN Org/ NomComRIWG

In Progress 

100#82

 

Org to continue working on charter revisions, present these on the 29th

ICANN OrgIn Progress
95#81

 

The NomComRIWG’s Status and Progress report will be delayed one month to provide a more comprehensive update on current implementation work NomComRIWG & ICANN Org

In Progress -   

93#81

 

Agreed to take several extra weeks to complete the progress update to the OEC, in order to include the various substantive areas of work currently underway.

NomComRIWG

In Progress 

88#80

 

Highlights of Standing Committee Charter Discussion (action items)

Scope and Reach:

  • Preamble with clear demarcation line over SC – need for clarity in drafting. This is drafting within the charter; some was in the preamble to the charter. (done)

Discussion on Main Categories of Legal Feedback:

  • Relationship with Other Entities:
    • Agree oversight needs to be clarified.  (done)
  • Governance:
    • Agree self-reinforcing is not the best. Already defined diversity, give OEC responsibility for staffing the SC. Key area for the Board. (in progress)
    • Role of the Board in charter amendments, there’s a role of the Board in change in charter amendments in all parts of ICANN.  (done)
NomComRIWGIn Progress
87#80

 

Standing Committee Charter revisions in response to presentation from Sam/Legal at the last meeting: At RIWG request, ICANN org (Review Support team) will take the notes from today’s call and propose edits to the latest draft of the Charter, as a starting point for RIWG edits.

NomComRIWG & ICANN OrgIn Progress
85#79

 

ICANN org will update the Action Item on Rec. 1 from Plenary Call #78 to read: 

  • Option for Revised Wiki Action Item: Rec. 1 Job Description: RIWG to request SO/ACs regularly post their final job descriptions for their respective NomCom delegates on their respective SO/AC websites, for transparency. The RIWG agreed that with this action, the implementation of Rec. 1 is complete.
ICANN Org (Teresa & Jia to facilitate)

 

83#79

 

RIWG will make adjustments to the Charter based upon feedback from ICANN Legal then share with ICANN Legal. 

NomComRIWGDuplicate action item - in progress - see item 78
78#77

 

Rec 27:  Considering the discussion and the takeaways, ICANN Legal will review the proposed definition and engage with the NomComRIWG to discuss a way forward.

ICANN OrgIn Progress
77#77

 

Rec 24:  ICANN org to provide to the RIWG consolidated feedback from the OEC and org on the Draft Standing Committee Charter for RIWG consideration.

ICANN OrgIn Progress

75

#75

 

RIWG will draft Operating Standards for the Standing Committee to complement the draft charter. 

NomComRIWGProposing to be done by Standing Committee
74#75

 

RIWG will consider adding language to the Standing Committee draft charter to convey "guard rails" for the work of the Standing Committee, and to add language regarding its accountability and transparency. 

NomComRIWG

 

71#74

 

NomCom Support Staff to try updating the process map with hyperlinks to the relevant sections of the NomCom Operating proceduresNomCom Support StaffOn hold
70#72

 

Draft Mapping - ICANN org to prepare a draft mapping of NomCom2 Review recommendations to relevant NomCom Operating Procedures for NomCom RIWG consideration.ICANN orgOn hold
65#69

 

Rec. 13:  Share latest version of the NomCom Lucid chart with NomCom support staff for review and to add any milestones that they believe are missingNomCom Supporton hold
64#68

 

ICANN org to confirm if they are aware of any questions generated in the recent past by the NomCom to the Board regarding feedback on re-applying nomcom appointees (rec 16)ICANN org - NomCom Support
63#68

 

WG is asking for a Blank copy of the Board's self-assessment template, as described here: https://www.icann.org/news/blog/chair-s-blog-key-takeaways-from-the-2020-board-self-evaluation [icann.org].ICANN org - NomCom SupportTBD
62#67

 

Rec. 23: Consult with the wider ICANN community what additional metrics they might want to collect. (questionnaire, poll on wiki)NomComRIWGBeing coordinated with item #103
61#67

 

Rec. 21: Schedule a discussion with HR to find out if they could suggest some assessment toolsICANN orgTBD
23#34

 

Rec.1: Wait before sending out job description to SOs/ACsNomComRIWG

 

10#6

 

Inquire about the contracting/procurement of recruitment consultants.

RT/Lars HoffmannTo be resolved during Implementation
9#6

 

HR for review of professional services hired to design recruiting materialsRT/Lars HoffmannTo be resolved during Implementation

...