View Source

The following two Google Docs summarize the RPM WG's deliberations on the URS Proposals submitted by Sub Teams and Individual WG members. These two Google Docs also note the approach of incorporating these proposals in the Initial Report.

Sub Team Proposals

WG revision to the URS Sub Team Proposals for the inclusion in the Initial Report (Drafted as of 12 December 2019, with redline edits): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jlsM6yl3A9ssPdHymjZwoSQXsncsl8h_9oOE1vFYm9o/edit?usp=sharing
Updated version (Drafted as of 24 October 2019) - Staff's attempt to refine the Sub Team proposals and close off the action items: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jlsM6yl3A9ssPdHymjZwoSQXsncsl8h_9oOE1vFYm9o/edit?usp=sharing
Archived version (Drafted as of 01 October 2018): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Wut5-zMqpDuwNbWXqLDebqe9wYa0EJJ_2prt8jdQOZY/edit?usp=sharing

Individual Proposals

WG Co-Chairs' designation on which URS Individual Proposals will be included in the Initial Report based on the WG survey/deliberation from October 2019 to January 2020: https://docs.google.com/document/d/110tgExAlgzrCbuiy0OiefXG2mKbo_SCLrU037zErN2k/edit
Results of the WG survey on which URS Individual Proposals should be published in the Initial Report(Published on 3 November 2019)
Updated document following ICANN63 Barcelona sessions (Draft as of 21 Oct 2018): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ky5uajo8WDfY9x6lbtaEQhb0xXzKVlMSZKFQkHXDE9s/edit?usp=sharing
Document presented in ICANN63 Barcelona (Draft as of 16 Oct 2018): https://docs.google.com/document/d/18LVAAr8Nb538DniTiHiyBRkfWGsaJNYWwCdaDCzyjUs/edit?usp=sharing

WG Revision to the URS Sub Team Proposals for inclusion in the Initial Report (version 12 December 2019, with redline edits): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jlsM6yl3A9ssPdHymjZwoSQXsncsl8h_9oOE1vFYm9o/edit?usp=sharing

Super Consolidated URS Proposals from Sub Teams (latest version 13 Sep 2018): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jxx9qmIBV9U-LjBM8j73f1X_UbzoyBogWz2phSMZ9lM/edit?usp=sharing

Download the consolidated URS Proposals submitted by individual working group members below:

Consolidated URS Proposals from Individual WG Members.pdf

Slides including survey results of all URS Individual Proposals

Order No.	Proponent	Topic (Mapped to the Super Consolidated URS Topics Table)	File	Tentative Presentation Date	Status	Updated Proposal
I. Suggested Operational Fix
Order No.	Proponent	Topic	File	Presentation Date	Status	Updated Proposal
1	Kristine Dorrain	B. NOTICE 3. Other topics	URS-Proposal-1.pdf	17 Sep 2018
2	Maxim Alzoba	F. REMEDIES 2. Duration of Suspension Period 3. Review of Implementation	URS-Proposal-2.pdf	17 Sep 2018
3	Zak Muscovitch	F. REMEDIES 2. Duration of Suspension Period 3. Review of Implementation	URS-Proposal-3.pdf	17 Sep 2018
4	George Kirikos	F. REMEDIES 4. Other topics	URS-Proposal-4.pdf	17 Sep 2018
II. Draft Policy Recommendation
5	George Kirikos	A. THE COMPLAINT 3. Limited filing period	URS-Proposal-5.pdf	10 Oct 2018
6	Claudio DiGangi	A. THE COMPLAINT 8. Other topics	URS-Proposal-6.pdf	17 Sep 2018		Supplemental Information
7	George Kirikos	B. NOTICE 1. Receipt by registrant (Notice - feedback from Complainant & Respondent)	URS-Proposal-7.pdf	10 Oct 2018
8	George Kirikos	C. RESPONSE 1. Duration of response period	URS-Proposal-8.pdf	10 Oct 2018
9	David McAuley	C. RESPONSE (primary topic) 1. Duration of response period == G. APPEAL (secondary topic) 2. De novo review	URS-Proposal-9.pdf	17 Sep 2018		#36 - merging #9 and #10 URS-Proposal-36.pdf
10	Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	C. RESPONSE (primary topic) 1. Duration of response period == G. APPEAL (secondary topic) 2. De novo review	URS-Proposal-10.pdf	26 Sep 2018
36	David McAuley & Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	C. RESPONSE (primary topic) 1. Duration of response period == G. APPEAL (secondary topic) 2. De novo review	URS-Proposal-36.pdf	20 Oct 2018
11	Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	C. RESPONSE 3. Response fee	URS-Proposal-11.pdf	26 Sep 2018
12	George Kirikos	D. STANDARD OF PROOF 1. General	URS-Proposal-12.pdf	10 Oct 2018		Revised version sent on 16 Oct 2018 URS-Proposal-35.pdf
35	George Kirikos	D. STANDARD OF PROOF 1. General	URS-Proposal-35.pdf	20 Oct 2018
13	Marie Pattullo (AIM - European Brands Association)	F. REMEDIES 1. Scope of remedies	URS-Proposal-13.pdf	10 Oct 2018
14	Marie Pattullo (AIM - European Brands Association)	F. REMEDIES 1. Scope of remedies	URS-Proposal-14.pdf	n/a		Can be merged
15	Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	F. REMEDIES 1. Scope of remedies	URS-Proposal-15.pdf	26 Sep 2018		Can be merged
16	Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	F. REMEDIES 1. Scope of remedies 2. Duration of suspension period	URS-Proposal-16.pdf	26 Sep 2018		Can be merged
17	Marie Pattullo (AIM - European Brands Association)	F. REMEDIES 2. Duration of suspension period	URS-Proposal-17.pdf	n/a		Can be merged
18	George Kirikos	G. APPEAL 1. Appeals process	URS-Proposal-18.pdf	10 Oct 2018
19	George Kirikos	G. APPEAL 1. Appeals process	URS-Proposal-19.pdf	10 Oct 2018
20	George Kirikos	G. APPEAL 1. Appeals process	URS-Proposal-20.pdf	10 Oct 2018
21	Marie Pattullo (AIM - European Brands Association)	I. COST 1. Cost allocation model	URS-Proposal-21.pdf	n/a		Can be merged
22	Brian Winterfeldt; Christopher Thomas; Colin O’Brien; Griffin Barnett; Jeff Neuman; John McElwaine; Lori Schulman; Pascal Boehner; Paul McGrady; Susan Payne	I. COST 1. Cost allocation model	URS-Proposal-22.pdf	03 Oct 2018		Can be merged
23	George Kirikos	I. COST 1. Cost allocation model	URS-Proposal-23.pdf	12 Oct 2018
24	George Kirikos	J. LANGUAGE ISSUES 1. Language issues, including current requirements for complaint, notice of complaint, response, determination	URS-Proposal-24.pdf	26 Sep 2018		#34 - merging #24 & #25 URS-Proposal-34.pdf
25	Zak Muscovitch	J. LANGUAGE ISSUES 1. Language issues, including current requirements for complaint, notice of complaint, response, determination	URS-Proposal-25.pdf	26 Sep 2018
34	George Kirikos & Zak Muscovitch	J. LANGUAGE ISSUES 1. Language issues, including current requirements for complaint, notice of complaint, response, determination	URS-Proposal-34.pdf	01 Oct 2018
26	Zak Muscovitch	M. URS PROVIERS 1. Evaluation of URS providers and their respective processes (including training of panelists)	URS-Proposal-26.pdf	03 Oct 2018
27	Zak Muscovitch	M. URS PROVIERS 1. Evaluation of URS providers and their respective processes (including training of panelists)	URS-Proposal-27.pdf	03 Oct 2018
28	Zak Muscovitch	M. URS PROVIERS 2. Conflict of interest	URS-Proposal-28.pdf	03 Oct 2018
29	George Kirikos	M. URS PROVIDERS (no applicable subheading at present)	URS-Proposal-29.pdf	03 Oct 2018
30	George Kirikos	N. ALTERNATIVE PROCESSES 1. Possible alternative(s) to the URS, e.g. summary procedure in the UDRP	URS-Proposal-30.pdf	03 Oct 2018
31	David McAuley	(no applicable subheading at present)	URS-Proposal-31.pdf	03 Oct 2018
III. Other
Order No.	Proponent	Topic	File	Tentative Presentation Date	Status	Updated Proposal
32	George Kirikos	N. ALTERNATIVE PROCESSES 1. Possible alternative(s) to the URS, e.g., summary procedure in the UDRP	URS-Proposal-32.pdf	12 Oct 2018
33	George Kirikos	(no applicable subheading at present)	URS-Proposal-33.pdf	12 Oct 2018

Download the consolidated URS Proposals submitted by individual working group members below:

Consolidated URS Proposals from Individual WG Members.pdf

I. Suggested Operational Fix

II. Draft Policy Recommendation

III. Other

Co-Chairs Proposed Procedures for URS Policy and Operational Recommendations-28 August 2018.pdf