Page History
| Wiki Markup |
|---|
h2. For Final Review * [RAPWG Draft Final - 27 May 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100527114839-0-25978/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2027%20May%202010.doc] \- redline version * [RAPWG Draft Final - clean version - 27 May 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100527114712-0-26953/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%20clean%20version%20-%2027%20May%202010.doc] \- clean version * [Attendance RAP May 2010.xls|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100527112723-0-22648/original/Attendance%20RAP%20May%202010.xls] * [Results of poll - 26 May 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100527114945-0-25485/original/Results%20of%20poll%20-%2026%20May%202010.doc] h2. Meeting Schedule *Next meeting of the Working Group* h4. Monday 24 May 2010 at 14:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [RAPWG Draft Final - 24 May 2010 edit19MayGCAFSBC.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100524091220-0-15522/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2024%20May%202010%20edit19MayGCAFSBC.doc] *Previous meetings* h4. Monday 17 May 2010 at 14:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [RAPWG Draft Final - 17 May 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100517090043-0-27358/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2017%20May%202010.doc] / [RAPWG Draft Final - 17 May 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100517132331-0-6839/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2017%20May%202010.pdf] * Public Comment Forum on Initial Report: [http://forum.icann.org/lists/rap-initial-report/|http://forum.icann.org/lists/rap-initial-report/] h4. Monday 3 May 2010 at 14:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [RAPWG Draft Final - 27 April 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100427124323-0-21173/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2027%20April%202010.doc] / [RAPWG Draft Final - 27 April 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100427124300-0-22117/original/RAPWG%20Draft%20Final%20-%2027%20April%202010.pdf] * Public Comment Forum on Initial Report: [http://forum.icann.org/lists/rap-initial-report/|http://forum.icann.org/lists/rap-initial-report/] Final Version of the Registration Abuse Policies Initial Report[RAPWG Initial Report - FINAL - 12 Feb 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100305160236-0-15347/original/RAPWG%20Initial%20Report%20-%20FINAL%20-%2012%20Feb%202010.pdf] * [Slamming_Rec04242010 JMB Comments.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100426142209-0-7213/original/Slamming_Rec04242010%20JMB%20Comments.pdf] * [Draft Initial Report - Updated 9 Feb 2010 MK.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100209130635-0-21026/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%20Updated%209%20Feb%202010%20MK.doc] * Clean version (no track changes or line numbers) [Draft Initial Report - Updated 9 Feb 2010 MK Clean.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100209130903-0-20943/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%20Updated%209%20Feb%202010%20MK%20Clean.pdf] / [Draft Initial Report - Updated 9 Feb 2010 MK Clean.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100209130556-0-20550/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%20Updated%209%20Feb%202010%20MK%20Clean.doc] Monday 08 February 2010 at 15:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [Draft Initial Report - Updated 8 Feb 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100208131603-0-29692/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%20Updated%208%20Feb%202010.pdf] / [Draft Initial Report - Updated 8 Feb 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100208131509-0-29297/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%20Updated%208%20Feb%202010.doc] * [Draft Initial Report - 2 Feb2010 - UPDATED MK.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100202192049-0-6705/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%202%20Feb2010%20-%20UPDATED%20MK.pdf] / [Draft Initial Report - 2 Feb2010 - UPDATED MK.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100202191835-0-5709/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%202%20Feb2010%20-%20UPDATED%20MK.doc] * [RAP WG Recommendations Survey Results – Updated 8 February 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100208083324-0-17325/original/RAP%20WG%20Recommendations%20Survey%20Results%20%E2%80%93%20Updated%208%20February%202010.doc] / [RAP WG Recommendations Survey Results – Updated 8 February 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100208083308-0-17136/original/RAP%20WG%20Recommendations%20Survey%20Results%20%E2%80%93%20Updated%208%20February%202010.pdf] Monday 01 February 2010 at 15:00 UTC (call duration 2h\+ and/or until the document has been reviewed) Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [Draft Initial Report - 27 January 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100127110637-0-4839/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%2027%20January%202010.pdf] / [Draft Initial Report - 27 January 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100127105126-0-4716/original/Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%2027%20January%202010.doc] * [RAP WG Survey – Initial Results 25 January 2010.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100127111057-1-6514/original/RAP%20WG%20Survey%20%E2%80%93%20Initial%20Results%2025%20January%202010.pdf] Monday 25 January 2010 at 15:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [RAPWG - Draft Initial Report - 20 January 2010[1].doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100122163355-0-30018/original/RAPWG%20-%20Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%2020%20January%202010%5B1%5D.doc] * [http://www.zoomerang.com/Survey/?p=WEB22A5E2J4K5Z|http://www.zoomerang.com/Survey/?p=WEB22A5E2J4K5Z] Monday 18 January 2010 at 15:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] For review: * [RAPWG - Draft Initial Report - 14 January 2010.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20100114184551-0-3844/original/RAPWG%20-%20Draft%20Initial%20Report%20-%2014%20January%202010.doc] Monday 4 January 2010 at 15:00 UTC Adobe Connect link: [http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/|http://icann.na3.acrobat.com/rap/] Reference materials: Wiki Page Gripe/Pornographic/Offensive/Deceptive Names (see [Gripe/Pornographic/Offensive/Deceptive Names|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?gripe_pornographic_offensive_deceptive_names] Wiki Page Uniformity Sub-Team (see [Uniformity Sub-Team|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?uniformity_sub_team]) Wiki Page on Phishing / Spam / Malware (see [Phishing / Spam / Malware|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?phishing_spam_malware]) Wiki Page on Domain Front Running (see [domain front running|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?domain_front_running]) Wiki Page on Malware/Botnet Control (see [Malware/Botnet Control|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?malware_botnet_control]) Wiki Page on Name Spinning (see [Name Spinning|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?name_spinning]) Wiki Page on Cybersquatting (see [Cybersquatting|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?cybersquatting]) Wiki Page on Abuse Definition (see [Abuse Definition|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?abuse_definition][RAPWG Abuse Categories and Types - 14 September 2009.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20090914105816-0-26812/original/RAPWG%20Abuse%20Categories%20and%20Types%20-%2014%20September%202009.pdf] / [RAPWG Abuse Categories and Types - 14 September 2009.doc|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20090914102604-0-26282/original/RAPWG%20Abuse%20Categories%20and%20Types%20-%2014%20September%202009.doc] Monday 21 December at 15:00 UTC Monday 14 December at 15:00 UTC Monday 7 December at 15.00 UTC Monday 30 November at 15.00 UTC Monday 23 November at 15.00 UTC Monday 9 November at 15.00 UTC Wednesday 27 October at 14:00 - 15:30 (local time), Sapphire 4 Proposed agenda: 1. Roll-call. 2. PPT update: WG history and issues 3. updates from sub-groups: a. Update from the “uniformity in contracts” group. What are the benefits of uniformity, and what specifically might the group recommend? Previous findings: [http://forum.icann.org/lists/gnso-rap-dt/msg00363.html|http://forum.icann.org/lists/gnso-rap-dt/msg00363.html] b. Spam/phishing/malware. Discuss a concise statement of the problem/issue as a way to help crystallize the issues. What are the policy issues here, and what might fall into other areas such as best practices? Background summarized at: [phishing spam malware|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?phishing_spam_malware] Last 30 minutes: 4. Questions and discussion with audience. 5. Discuss delivery of Initial Report by Nairobi ICANN meeting (March 7-12, 2010) Monday 12 October at 14.00 UTC Monday 28 September at 14.00 UTC Monday 14 September at 14.00 UTC See [Previous Meetings|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?previous_meetings] h2. Documents[Registration Abuse Polices WG - Status Update - FINAL - 2 June 2009.pdf|https://community.icann.org/data/workspaces/reg-abuse-wg/attachments/registration_abuse_policies_working_group:20090602072513-0-4587/original/Registration%20Abuse%20Polices%20WG%20-%20Status%20Update%20-%20FINAL%20-%202%20June%202009.pdf] h2. Charter Whereas GNSO Council Resolution (20081218-3) dated December 18, 2008 called for the creation of a drafting team “to create a proposed charter for a working group to investigate the open issues documented in the issues report on Registrations\[sic\] Abuse Policy”. Whereas a drafting team has formed and its members have discussed and reviewed the open issues documented in the issues report. Whereas it is the view of the drafting Team that the objective of the Working Group should be to gather facts, define terms, provide the appropriate focus and definition of the policy issue(s), if any, to be addressed, in order to enable the GNSO Council to make an informed decision as to whether to launch PDP on registration abuse. Whereas the drafting team recommends that the GNSO Council charter a Working Group to \(i) further define and research the issues outlined in the Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report; and (ii) take the steps outlined below. The Working Group should complete its work before a decision is taken by the GNSO Council on whether to launch a PDP. The GNSO Council RESOLVES: To form a Working Group of interested stakeholders and Constituency representatives, to collaborate broadly with knowledgeable individuals and organizations, to further define and research the issues outlined in the Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report; and take the steps outlined in the Charter. The Working Group should address the issues outlined in the Charter and report back to the GNSO Council within 90 days following the end of the ICANN meeting in Mexico City. *CHARTER* *Scope and definition of registration abuse* -- the Working Group should define domain name registration abuse, as distinct from abuse arising solely from use of a domain name while it is registered. The Working Group should also identify which aspects of the subject of registration abuse are within ICANN's mission to address and which are within the set of topics on which ICANN may establish policies that are binding on gTLD registry operators and ICANN-accredited registrars. This task should include an illustrative categorization of known abuses. *Additional research and identifying concrete policy issues* -- The issues report outlines a number of areas where additional research would be needed in order to understand what problems may exist in relation to registration abuse and their scope, and to fully appreciate the current practices of contracted parties, including research to: * ‘Understand if registration abuses are occurring that might be curtailed or better addressed if consistent registration abuse policies were established’ * ‘Determine if and how {registration} abuse is |
...
dealt with in those registries {and registrars} that do not have any specific {policies} in place’
* ‘Identify how these registration abuse provisions are {...} implemented in practice or deemed effective in addressing registration abuse’.
In addition, additional research should be conducted to include the practices of relevant entities other than the contracted parties, such as abusers, registrants, law enforcement, service providers, and so on.
The Working Group should determine how this research can be conducted in a timely and efficient manner \-\- by the Working Group itself via a Request for Information (RFI), by obtaining expert advice, and/or by exploring other options.
Based on the additional research and information, the Working Group should identify and recommend specific policy issues and processes for further consideration by the GNSO Council.
*SSAC Participation and Collaboration*
The Working Group should \(i) consider inviting a representative from the Security and Stability Advisory Committee (SSAC) to participate in the Working Group; (ii) consider in further detail the SSAC’s invitation to the GNSO Council to participate in a collaborative effort on abuse contacts; and (iii) make a recommendation to the Council about this invitation.
*Workshop at ICANN meeting in Mexico City on Registration Abuse Policies* \- In order to get broad input on and understanding of the specific nature of concerns from community stakeholders, the drafting team proposes to organize a workshop on registration abuse policies in conjunction with the ICANN meeting in Mexico City. The Working Group should review and take into account the discussions and recommendations, if any, from this workshop in its deliberations.
The working group established by this motion will work according to the process defined in [Working Group Processes|https://st.icann.org/gnso-council/index.cgi?working_group_process].
h2. Background Information
[SAC038: Registrar Abuse Contacts (26 February 2009)|http://www.icann.org/committees/security/sac038.pdf]
[GNSO Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report|http://gnso.icann.org/issues/registration-abuse/gnso-issues-report-registration-abuse-policies-29oct08.pdf]
[Executive Summary of Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report in Spanish|http://gnso.icann.org/issues/registration-abuse/gnso-issues-report-registration-abuse-policies-29oct08-es.pdf]
[Executive Summary of Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report in French|http://gnso.icann.org/issues/registration-abuse/gnso-issues-report-registration-abuse-policies-29oct08-fr.pdf]
[Executive Summary of Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report in Russian|http://gnso.icann.org/issues/registration-abuse/gnso-issues-report-registration-abuse-policies-29oct08-ru.pdf]
[Executive Summary of Registration Abuse Policies Issues Report in Arab|http://gnso.icann.org/issues/registration-abuse/gnso-issues-report-registration-abuse-policies-29oct08-ar.pdf]
h2. Mailing List Archive
[http://forum.icann.org/lists/gnso-rap-dt/|http://forum.icann.org/lists/gnso-rap-dt/]
h2. Members of the Working Group
| *Name* | *Affiliation* |
| Greg Aaron (Chair) | Registry |
| Mike Rodenbaugh (Council Liaison) | CBUC |
| James Bladel | Registrar |
| Olga Cavalli | NCA |
| Zahid Jamil | CBUC |
| Beau Brendler | ALAC |
| Jeff Neuman | Registry |
| Nacho Amadoz | Registry |
| Philip Corwin | CBUC |
| Martin Sutton | CBUC |
| Richard Tindal | Registrar |
| Greg Ogorek | |
| Faisal Shah | IPC |
| Roland Perry | Individual |
| Paul Stahura | Registrar |
| Jaime Echeverry Gomez | Registrar |
| Li Guanghao | |
| Mike O'Connor | CBUC |
| Gretchen Olive | |
| Berry Cobb | |
| Jeff Eckhaus | Registrar |
| Robert Hutchinson | |
| Andy Steingruebl | |
| Jeremy Hitchcock | SSAC |
| Patrick Kane | Registry |
| | |
| Michael Young | Registry |
| Rod Rasmussen | Individual |
| Edward Nunes | NCUC |
| Frederick Felman | IPC |
| -Evan Leibovitch- | -ALAC- |
| Caleb Queern | CBUC |
| Avri Doria (GNSO Chair) | NCA |
| Chuck Gomes (GNSO Vice-Chair) | Registry |
h2. Statements of Interest
See [Statements of Interest|https://community.icann.org/index.cgi?statements_of_interest] |
