AC Chat THICK WHOIS 4 August 2015 Nathalie Peregrine:Dear all, Welcome to the Thick Whois Implementation IRT Meeting on Thursday 4th August 2015 Nathalie Peregrine:There are two ways to connect to this call's audio. First, by activating your AC room mic by clicking on the telephone icon on the top toolbar and following instructions there. When activated, the telephone icon will become a microphone icon. To mute and unmute please click on the microphone icon throughout the call. Alternatively, please dial into the audio bridge, dial in details are in the meeting invitation Nathalie Peregrine:Steve Metalitz and Carlton Samuels have joined Carlton Samuels:Howdy everybody Nathalie Peregrine:Krista Papac from staff is also on the call Nathalie Peregrine:Amr Elsadr has joined the call Sara Bockey:I note that my title has changed since I joined. My SOI has been updated. New title is Policy Manager - just FYI Amr Elsadr:Does privacy/proxy not being an option include registrars that do not offer privacy/proxy services? Could there also be an option for transfering the domain name registration to a registrar that does offer them? Don Blumenthal:.US doesn't offer it. However, are we covering ccTLDs? Roger Carney:Is there more details on the regionalized whois service? Amr Elsadr:@Don: I don't think so. The scope of policies developed by the GNSO only cover domain names registered under gTLDs. Right? steve metalitz:If the probabliity of options is to be quantified, 1(c) should be approaching zero. Carlton Samuels:@Amr: Right. Carlton Samuels:@Steve: If we talking about the existing thin registries I think you're right; tending to zero is in the ballpark Roger Carney:sorry mic not working Roger Carney:will type in Nathalie Peregrine:Roger, we can dial out to you if needed, please pm me your phone number Roger Carney:go ahead I will ask Roger Carney:Just wanting to clarify Joes approach. Instead of starting with the consent you are suggesting to start with new/current registration and then move into the consent question? Roger Carney:Ok, thanks for clarifying Joe Amr Elsadr:@Steve: Doesn't that text actually help differentiatie 1a from 1c? Not sure I understand the concern. steve metalitz:@Amr, I think there are other ways to do that more clearly , which I'll suggest in drafting suggestions. Amr Elsadr:OK. Thanks Steve. Carlton Samuels:Have to step away now for a competing meeting Don Blumenthal:Amr, correct on GNSO. I've been largely off the grid for awhile so I wanted to make sure I hadn't missed something when I heard references to European ccTLDs. Amr Elsadr:@Joe: My guess would be the location of the registrar is what ultimately matters, not the registrant. Roger Carney:Sorry still cant hear me :) Roger Carney:Will do Jody Kolker:Who will implement the regional thick whois data stores? Roger Carney:2013 RAA says that we can stop providing WHOIS for all thick registries, how do we account for that? Jody Kolker:Ok. Roger Carney:Yes, just something to think about and discuss steve metalitz:@Roger, I believe that RAA provision applies only to port 43 Whois, not web-based Whois. Roger Carney:@steve true, but how would we support any "redirection" steve metalitz:@Mike, +1. Don Blumenthal:Have to drop for my third consecutive 1 hour call. Fabien Betremieux:Thank you Don Amr Elsadr:Thanks Krista, and thanks Mikey for helping get this clarified. :) Roger Carney:I know ICANN meeting schedules are set early, Is there a plan for this group to meet at ICANN54? Roger Carney:Sorry about the audio issues, but thatnks for the discussions!! Amr Elsadr:Thanks all. Bye.