00:14:59 Kimberly Carlson: Hope all are well. Welcome to today’s ccPDP Review Mechanism Working Group teleconference on 22 April at 23:59 UTC. In the interest of time, attendance will be taken based on those Zoom. Apologies have been received from: Eberhard Lisse, Jaap Akkerhuis, Mirjana Tasić, Svitlana Tkachenko, Mzia Gogilashvili. As a reminder, calls are recorded and transcribed; recording and transcript (along with supporting document) will be posted on the public wiki space: Please also remember to mute your phones and mics when not speaking to avoid background noise and echoing. 00:16:14 Kimberly Carlson: Omitted the wiki link above: https://community.icann.org/x/qyyJBw 00:16:38 Allan MacGillivray: Congratulations Stephen 00:16:59 Belaid NOUAR: Hello , I hope that everyone and their families are well and safe. 00:17:27 Nick Wenban-Smith, Nominet: Congrats Stephen 00:17:42 Nick Wenban-Smith, Nominet: Glutton for punishment ;) 00:21:05 vandascartezini: yes remember 00:21:25 Angela - NIC.BW: I think Page 3 00:22:10 Stephen Deerhake: Thank you Nick. And thank you for getting up in the middle of the night ;-) 00:22:18 Kimberly Carlson: Thank you Angela 00:22:28 Stephen Deerhake: Indeed, thank you Angela. 00:22:50 Stephen Deerhake: Good call Maarten, 00:22:51 vandascartezini: guess we agreed needed to put into positive so it is done 00:23:18 Angela - NIC.BW: and perhaps add a "," after list 00:23:21 Nick Wenban-Smith, Nominet: yes agreed word missing line 29 00:23:46 Stephen Deerhake: And the comma as well. 00:24:03 vandascartezini: none 00:24:19 vandascartezini: no 00:24:33 vandascartezini: done 00:24:45 vandascartezini: ok 00:28:50 Anna Karakhanyan: Most of participants are between UTC +0 and UTC +4, so it is deep night now for them 00:29:28 Anna Karakhanyan: Thank you 00:33:30 Kimberly Carlson: Survey was circulated earlier and posted on the wiki 00:42:03 Sean Copeland: I agree with Nick 00:47:50 Peter Koch: 8h rotation really depends on the exact time slots, IMHO; 22:00, 06:00 and 14:00 is much different from 00:00, 08:00 and 16:00 [UTC, that is]; both in terms of convenience and daytime duty collisions 00:48:23 vandascartezini: ARTR3 is rotating 11UTC and 21 UTC 00:48:42 vandascartezini: now 00:49:33 vandascartezini: guess depend on the spread of members we have around the world 00:51:37 Maarten Simon, SIDN: Agree with Peter (but am in the exact same time zone) 00:58:32 vandascartezini: yes 00:59:36 Stephen Deerhake: We will discuss the meeting timings after Allan has completed. 01:03:25 Angela - NIC.BW: Does the ombudsman feature anywhere, say if the Board cant resolve an escalated matter? 01:04:12 vandascartezini: guess no Angela but good point ! 01:04:34 Belaid NOUAR: is not clear since the second step, if CSC seeks resolution with PTI is resolved what then should be happened? and what the role of ICANN CEO and ICANN board 01:06:05 Stephen Deerhake: I believe the Ombudsperson is not relevant to this procedure, but I may be wrong... ;-) 01:08:04 Naela Sarras: +1 to Bart’s point. This process if for the CSC to monitor the IANA Performance and to address performance issues when identified. The review mechanism this group is working on seems to me to be a different scope. The review mechanism should be exactly that, a review first to identify if there was an issue to start with. 01:09:17 vandascartezini: certainly shall be under our consideration here 01:09:48 vandascartezini: we should suggest rethink this process' 01:12:20 Allan MacGillivray: I think that we need to have a close look at the IRP 01:12:49 vandascartezini: no 01:12:59 Kimberly Carlson: Webinar #1 | 23 April 2020 | 21:00 UTC 01:13:03 vandascartezini: tomorrow ? 01:13:10 Kimberly Carlson: Webinar #2 | 24 April 2020 | 11:00 UTC 01:13:27 Anna Karakhanyan: 21:00 is good, thank you 01:13:39 Kimberly Carlson: I will send this list the registration details 01:15:37 ppoblete: Sorry, awfully late 01:15:49 ppoblete: I had the time wrong by 1 hour :-( 01:16:09 vandascartezini: lets do in the list to think better on each alternative 01:18:25 Adenike: Let's discuss this on the list. Thank you 01:21:26 vandascartezini: thanks to all 01:22:04 Anna Karakhanyan: Thanks to everyone 01:22:06 Rocío de la Fuente: Thank you all! Goodbye