Zoom chat: 2020-04-15 Consolidated Policy Working Group Call

00:20:06 Heidi Ullrich: Welcome, All.
00:20:28 Heidi Ullrich: Action Items for today’s call will be noted at: https://community.icann.org/display/atlarge/Action+items%3A+2020-04-15+Consolidated+Policy+Working+Group+Call
00:21:40 Claudia Ruiz: https://www.streamtext.net/player?event=ICANN [streamtext.net]
00:22:54 Filina Natalia (EURALO Secretary): Hello all! sorry I am late
00:23:41 Heidi Ullrich: All AIs have been completed
00:24:29 davekissoondoyal: Hello everyone.Sorry for being late
00:24:57 Michel TCHONANG: Hi everyone
00:25:24 León Felipe Sánchez Ambía: hello everyone!
00:25:31 Heidi Ullrich: Welcome, Leon.
00:26:06 Michel TCHONANG: Hi Heidi how are you?
00:26:19 Jonathan Zuck: What’s the rush during the lockdown?
00:26:30 Matthias M. Hudobnik: hey leon :-)
00:26:36 Heidi Ullrich: I’m well, Michel. I hope you are well, too!
00:27:27 Marita Moll: The GAC letter was asking that the workschedule be adjusted to recognize the social pressures right now
00:31:26 iPad (27): sorry to enter little late - I am in another call but I will be listen to this call
00:32:31 christopher wilkinson: @JZ Rush? Indeed.
00:41:16 Alan Greenberg: Support input re IRT
00:42:40 Alfredo Calderon (ISOCPR): Apologies for being late. Had to deal with another call.
00:49:52 Marita Moll: Rational was that a longer comment period put community applications at a disadvantage, right?
00:54:07 avri doria: (Personally speaking) I am sure Jamie from dotgay could easily produce one.
00:54:13 Jonathan Zuck: Agree
00:55:31 Olivier Crépin-Leblond: Good idea, Jonathan
00:55:58 Sarah Kiden: Sounds great
00:56:06 Marita Moll: I did have discussions with Jamie quite a long time ago and can probably find those e-mails, if need be.
00:56:26 Jonathan Zuck: That would be great. I think Avri worked on .gay as well, right?
00:58:24 avri doria: I did Jonathan, but I find it hard to advocate for specific postions at the moment. So would not be a strong protagonist.
00:58:27 Jonathan Zuck: cool
00:58:51 Marita Moll: I think you can interpret silence as agreement
00:59:09 Michel TCHONANG: +1 Marita
00:59:14 Jonathan Zuck: @Avri, I guess I’d be interested in your objective, perhaps even hypothetical, appraisal of how the CPE process worked and how it might be improved
01:00:31 avri doria: as Board co-liaison to the SubPro PDP it would be awkward. But will think on it.
01:08:09 Jonathan Zuck: Sounds quite reasonable
01:08:42 Jonathan Zuck: guess the concern is that on a generic, there might be more “bribes” to change applications?
01:12:01 Jonathan Zuck: And NOT confusingly similar!
01:14:26 Jonathan Zuck: Then NO WAY!
01:15:34 Jonathan Zuck: good point @Seb
01:16:45 Cheryl Langdon-Orr: I would think it is important to also note from the email we sent to SubPro regarding how we are finalising the Report as well with the completed topics this week we have released these topics as clean text. "... 2.4.1 Applicant Guidebook, 2.4.2 Communications, 2.4.3 Systems, 2.5.1 Application Fees/2.5.2 Variable Fees (these two are combined into a single section), 2.5.3 Application Submission Period, and 2.5.5 Terms & Conditions. Revisions are based on Working Group feedback, discussion on calls, and mailing list contributions. The purpose of this exercise is to prepare sections for the draft Final Report so that the draft Final Report can be published for public comment. This is not a consensus call. BUT SubPro expects that Members will be listing things they "Can Not live with" and provide text of any proposed changes, via a standard form. The deadline for comments from WG members on these sections (package 1) is Tuesday 21 April at 23:59 UTC.
01:16:54 Marita Moll: I agree with Justine and Alan on the issue of not allowing certain changes
01:17:40 Justine Chew: Sorry folks, I have again goine over time :(
01:18:11 Justine Chew: *gone over time
01:19:07 Heidi Ullrich: All, Olivier has had to drop off the call. Jonathan will chair the remainder of the call.
01:20:03 Cheryl Langdon-Orr: Mearly a NEW opportunity I wanted to raise NOTHING more just a fact
01:22:37 Filina Natalia (EURALO Secretary): Sorry, need to leave the call for my next one...
01:23:46 Justine Chew: @Jonathan, I had taken more than my 30 minutes, unless we have time AFTER we have considered everything else on today's agenda, I will try and pick up on Applicant Support consensus next week.
01:24:34 Jonathan Zuck: ok
01:27:08 Hadia Elminiawi: the comment ends 5th May
01:28:20 Hadia Elminiawi: hopefully next time we could have a draft ready on the addendum
01:29:09 Jonathan Zuck: Starting to go mainstream as well..
01:29:11 Jonathan Zuck: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9x7KRdG-zgE
01:30:48 Matthias M. Hudobnik: http://www.interisle.net/domainregistrationdata.html
01:31:37 Matthias M. Hudobnik: this was the report i was refering to just in case if somebody might be interested :-)
01:31:44 Alan Greenberg: Regarding the Interilse report, at least one registrar named in the report responded (privately) "I'll fix those problems". Others were not quite that supportive (and that is an gross understatement!)
01:32:48 Hadia Elminiawi: @Mathias yes this is the report we were talking about a summary of it can also be found at http://www.circleid.com/posts/20200331-at-the-crossroads-the-state-of-domain-registration-data-services/
01:32:50 Heidi Ullrich: Finance, Budget and Operations Sub-Committee will be the new name of the FBSC.
01:33:13 Michel TCHONANG: ok thank Heidi
01:33:15 Maureen Hilyard (ALAC): Nice plug, Jonathan
01:33:16 Matthias M. Hudobnik: indeed! thx alan and hadia
01:35:33 Cheryl Langdon-Orr: Excellent @JZ!
01:35:50 Hadia Elminiawi: great video
01:36:01 Sarah Kiden: Very nice
01:41:07 Michelle DeSmyter: Wiki page link to CPWG Single Issue call for 16, April: https://community.icann.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=132087994
01:45:13 Michelle DeSmyter: Next meeting: Wednesday, 22 April at 13:00 UTC
01:45:40 Cheryl Langdon-Orr: Bye for now
01:45:44 herb.waye: stay safe everyone
01:45:51 Leon Felipe Sanchez: Thanks everyone
01:45:52 Sarah Kiden: Thank you!
01:45:59 Hadia Elminiawi: bye - stay safe and healthy
01:46:01 Marita Moll: Okay, thanks everyone. Bye till tomorrow
01:46:04 Matthias M. Hudobnik: bye
01:46:04 Katambi Joan (ISOC UGANDA): thanks all
01:46:04 Alberto Soto: Thanks, bye bye
01:46:05 Justine Chew: 20 participants expected for CPE single issue call
01:46:05 Matthias M. Hudobnik: thx